ArabianBusiness.com - Middle East Business News Monday, 07 July 2008 | 06:09 UAE time
 
 
 
Wadah Khanfar: Wadah's world
Friday, 12 October 2007

For a man who has been accused of many things in his life, Wadah Khanfar appears remarkably relaxed. "Working for the Israelis. Working for the Americans. Then working for Saddam Hussein, then working for this group and that group. There is no surprise in the accusations any more. It makes me laugh but it doesn't make me angry," says the director general of the Al Jazeera Network.

Right now, Khanfar is very much having the last laugh. The television station that he heads has become one of the world's most recognisable brands and now has over 130 million viewers globally. The launch of the English version of the news channel a year ago has been an undisputed success, and now even the Americans - who steadfastly refused to allow Al Jazeera onto their networks - are taking notice of the station as a serious news broadcaster.

Had the figures within the American administration that criticised us been watching Al Jazeera carefully they would never have made as many mistakes in Iraq.
From a controversial satellite broadcaster that first hit the airwaves 11 years ago and quickly became the centre of unwanted attention for its airing of Al Qaeda video messages, Al Jazeera has now grown into a world-class operation - spanning not just English and Arabic rolling news channels, but a massive web operation, hugely profitable sports channels and even a media training centre that could one day become the Al Jazeera University of Journalism.

Story continues below
advertisement

Thanks to the deep pockets of the Qatari government, nearly US$1bn has been spent, however group profits are some years away, but more importantly for Al Jazeera, the public perception of the channel has greatly improved.

Much of the credit goes to Khanfar - voted the world's third most powerful Arab in last year's Arabian Business Power List, the Jordanian former mechanical engineer has deflected both the criticism and quite literally, the bullets. Things came to a head last year after revelations that President Bush had even considered bombing the station's Doha headquarters, so worried was he about its influence in the Arab world.

It is something Khanfar is not about to forget easily. "In our case, someone talks about bombing a TV station, a civilian TV station with people that are working from different nationalities from all over the world. A TV station that speaks about freedom of expression, a TV station that has been leading the concept of freedom of expression. I mean that is outrageous. It is completely outside the parameters of any reasonable criticism."

He adds: "I was sad because always the concept of a free media and democracy has come to us here in the Middle East unfortunately from the West. That momentum of pushing forward for democracy came from the West. The same West was pushing in the other direction as far as that particular incident was concerned. I did not like it. This is not the America that we knew. This is not the culture that we respected. You know, sometimes lies by certain figures who are supposed to be responsible and accountable makes me angry. These people appear on television and at press conferences and repeat certain lies that fortunately have not been proved. That is something I do not understand because basically I demand much higher moral standards from people who speak on behalf of public institutions."

It is these high standards that have helped to radically transform Al Jazeera Network. The Arabic version has more than 40 bureaus across the globe, and made thought-provoking live broadcasts during the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. The English version now reaches more than 80 million homes and has 60 global bureaus, with the likes of Sir David Frost and Riz Khan in front of the camera.

Initially, most American cable operators refused to air the channel, claiming it was a propaganda tool for Al Qaeda. But nearly a year of broadcasting has changed perceptions in the West and Al Jazeera English is now becoming increasingly watched - and available - in the US. It is already established in many parts of Europe, South Africa and Asia.


Khanfar says: "Always when you are speaking about media institutions there will be perceptions that exist that have been promoted unjustly by some people - by certain core groups at the centres of power that were accusing Al Jazeera of promoting Osama Bin Laden. Okay, that is now fading away simply because people can see for themselves the high standards that Al Jazeera is adopting. I don't think in any moment of time that the strategy of Al Jazeera has been mistaken, even if it has invoked certain kinds of response and provocations and anger from certain politically-motivated circles."

He adds: "Had the figures within the American administration that criticised us been watching Al Jazeera carefully they would never have made as many mistakes in Iraq.



We have seen the rise of patriotism in journalism. We have seen a departure from the well-established rules of journalism. Unfortunately some media organisations have been completely taking sides.
"I mean really they should have viewed Al Jazeera because it would have given them a perspective that they have missed and therefore that led to a lot of problems in Iraq," he adds.

Khanfar knows more than most about Iraq, and working inside Iraq. He set up Al Jazeera's operation in Baghdad before the start of the second Gulf War, and at the time of the American invasion, was running a team of more than 100 people. The station's output was not only to the displeasure of the invading Americans, unhappy that their opponents were being given any kind of airtime, but even many Iraqis. But Khanfar, despite intense pressure from the US administration, refused to budge - citing the importance of balanced reporting, and giving every opinion broadcast a counter-opinion.

Eventually, the station left Iraq but Khanfar has no regrets, saying: "I was always conscious that we should never be consumed by the superficial events. A war is not about military air strikes, and the movement of armies and all these kinds of issues. It is about human beings. It is about the human being who is being killed and about the human being who is doing the killing. The proper journalist looks into this culture and is not consumed by other things. Some of our colleagues have just been consumed by giving data. It is not about giving data, it is about giving spirit. And that is important, and I think Al Jazeera has been able to capture that."

Not that this way of thinking has made his life any easier or safer. "In many cases people would see something on the television and they might respond to it and you don't know how they will respond to it. Sometimes they get angry. We have been attacked many times in our bureau by certain groups. They shot at us. Some of my colleagues have lost their lives, some have been arrested and some have been kidnapped. There is a huge diversity of people in Iraq so you cannot predict the reaction of that angry group or this angry group to what you are broadcasting."

Apart from the fact that a number of journalists have been killed while covering the war in Iraq, the style of coverage has left many media organisations bitterly divided. Khanfar himself doesn't hide his disgust with the way some broadcasters operated, saying it was a low point for the profession. "I really believe that the media coverage of what happened in Baghdad was a turning point in the history of journalism. We have seen a lot of views on the way journalism is covered internationally; we have seen the rise of patriotism in journalism. We have seen a departure from the well-established rules of journalism. Unfortunately some media organisations have been completely taking sides."

Al Jazeera is of course in the rare position of not having to chase profits. The Qatari government is not demanding to see the accounts turn from red to black, and there are few, if any, commercial pressures on the station. Nevertheless, Khanfar insists that the coverage of the war in Iraq exposed the true colours of many of his rivals. "It will be very alarming the moment we realise that this profession is threatened by two major elements - political influence and commercial influence. Both of them are tied. A lot of media organisations are owned by commercial groups that have their own political interests, so they prefer to go with the establishment rather than going against it, because at the end of the month they would like to achieve profits. This is a great danger for the integrity of the profession."

He adds: "At Al Jazeera we have been liberated from those two chains. In my opinion we need to introduce an environment that isolates journalists from all these pressures. We need to make a distance. How do we do it? Until now we are still searching for that answer because the media has been commercialised too much and that is something that we need to find a way out of. To be commercial by itself is not a problem. To make profits is okay, however, to submit your editorial standards to commercial ends, that is a problem. To play around with your editorial integrity in order to get some kind of advertising deal, that is a problem. Some media organisations have succeeded and they have become really well-established because of their integrity. And they also make money - so money is not only made by departing from the normal rules."

Ironically, it is the normal rules of making money that Al Jazeera is now tackling - they may be deep, but the pockets of the Qatari government are not a bottomless pit. Khanfar is now restructuring the way the company is run, having brought in a new commercial division. He admits profits may still be five years away, but the financial corner has definitely been turned.

"News is always expensive and will always consume money. According to my calculations most international news channels do not make money. However the news is vital to build your brand because without a brand you cannot do anything else. We have established our brand name because of the news. Now we are looking at other ideas," he says.



They shot at us. Some of my colleagues have lost their lives, some have been arrested and some have been kidnapped.

The addition of a website and subscription-driven sports channels are a huge part of this plan, and Khanfar is now looking at making more use of many of the bureaus dotted around the globe - turning them from cost centres into assets. Other new ventures are likely to be rolled out in the next 12 months, and with an expected growth in the US market, the change from loss to profit could yet be quicker than expected.

Either way, Khanfar has a lot on his plate - not that his calm demeanour shows it. Still just 39 years old, the Jordanian has excelled in everything he has tackled so far. Between 1985 and 1990, while studying at the University of Jordan, he started a student's union that soon spread to several other universities. By 1989 the Student's Union was playing an active role in debating the future of the democratic process, and Khanfar started making a name for himself as a charismatic and natural leader - not to mention a great public speaker. His first job for Al Jazeera was as a correspondent in South Africa in 1997, before heading to Afghanistan and later Iraq, where he was chief of the Baghdad bureau.

He became managing director of Al Jazeera in 2003, and director general three years later. "Al Jazeera should be led by someone with a vision. To run a place like this, management is very important but you need to have visionary leadership. Management can be achieved through many schools of thought. I prefer always to lead through inspiring people and giving them a vision for the future," he says.

Khanfar's personal vision for the future is to document many of the station's experiences and transfer them into educational uses. A dedicated Al Jazeera training centre has already been established, but in the long-term Khanfar is hopeful that the world may one day be filled with Al Jazeera Universities of Journalism.

He says, "What motivates me is the audience of Al Jazeera, they are not like any other audience. For many it is an extension of their lives. Some of them tell me that if they don't watch Al Jazeera they cannot start their day. That is very inspiring. It makes you feel that you are not doing this for very limited gain, but because there are millions of people out there relying on you. And you don't want to disappoint them, you need to give them your best."

Nobody could ever accuse Khanfar of failing to do that.

Wadah Khanfar will be speaking at the Arabian Business Media and Marketing Conference in Dubai on November 11-12.

The world on Al Jazeera

Sir David Frost, presenter on Al Jazeera

"I obviously investigated before I signed on, talking to friends in Whitehall and in Washington. That made it quite an easy decision. I think all these stories have faded away. Even before Al Jazeera English started that sort of propaganda was all vastly exaggerated. Once it went on the air people could see for themselves that these stories weren't true. None of those lurid things apply. They have received a lot of plaudits for their news coverage. I ran into Norman Lamont (former British Chancellor of the Exchequer) the other day who said he was a bit of a news junkie and that the station was always telling him things he didn't know in terms of world coverage. They cover stories abut Brazil and Indonesia and other countries that we don't often hear of. This sort of coverage sets it apart."

Roy Greenslade, Professor of Journalism at London's City University

"As far as the US is concerned, it's still TV Bin Laden. One of its main problems there is it can't get on the air which I think is quite disgraceful in the Land of Opportunity. Nobody's going to force people to watch it, but at least they should have the choice. It does have a refreshingly different approach to stories. It doesn't have the Western spin but rather a Middle Eastern spin. If any major Western news editor had an inside track on a story of worldwide significance such as Al Qaeda it would have been manna from heaven and they did a very responsible job covering it, cutting out the worst bits. Instead they were pilloried for it."

CNN spokesperson Susanna Flood

"There's no doubt that the launch of Al Jazeera English was a significant move in terms of the expansion of international news channels - but it's important to keep it in context as one of a number of launches that have taken place over the last year or so. Among others, we have also seen the launch of France 24, funded by the French government and Russia Today, funded by the Russian government, and more recently the launch of Press TV, the English language television service from Iran. This expansion certainly helps focus attention on the 24-hour news genre and healthy competition helps supports growth more broadly in the television news business, in terms of distribution and content sales."


Click on the regions of the map below to indicate residence of Power 100 entries

 
Comments (83)

Wonderful Younis!
Posted by Amira on 8 June 2008 at 00:40 UAE time

YEAH!!! Younis Mahmoud is on the list! :D
It's great to see him known as an influential person
Dual nationality
Posted by Deborah, Manama, Bahrain on 27 May 2008 at 11:55 UAE time

Interesting.
But why is it that Afnan Al Zayani is both Bahrain's and Egypt's most powerful woman?
A joke
Posted by Johar, Djanet, Algeria on 10 May 2008 at 20:19 UAE time

These people may be influential in the Middle East but not in the World.

Who cares about Elissa and her fake rack and bad nose job outside the region?

Editors' Reply: Elissa gives joy and happiness to the many millions of Arabic speaking people who love her music and videos. We do not have to seek the approval of what is outside our culture to give recognition to what is within.
A good list
Posted by salah almhamdi, sbiba, tunisia on 10 May 2008 at 17:55 UAE time

I was very glad that scientists appears on the list...
the list is excellent
Posted by salah almhamdi, sbiba, tunisia on 10 May 2008 at 17:53 UAE time

I thank all the staff of the magazine for this comprehensive list. but where is Nishan? He is very influential. Please include him in the list next year , he succeeded in hosting George Wassouf who rarely accepts TV appearances...
Selection criteria
Posted by Maher Ahmed, London, United Kingdom on 9 May 2008 at 14:38 UAE time

It is an interesting list and hard to argue for or against many. The one point I would make is that the selection criteria seems very shallow and tends to favour those who were born into privileged backgrounds and those who basically have a lot of money. Nothing wrong with that but I think it ignores some people who have achieved great things and have maybe not got the media attention that their achievements deserved, people who would inspire the ordinary masses on the street.

The examples I have in mind are people such as Sir Magdi Yacoub, one of the greatest transplant surgeons in the world, his work still influences today's surgery or Zaid 'Zeddy' Al Refai, the first Arab to climb everest and one of less than 100 people in the world who have climbed the highest mountains on every continent in the world. Maybe even someone like the Aga Khan, not an Arab, but his work has benefited a lot of less privileged people in the Middle East.
Where is Mohamed El-Erian?
Posted by mo, London, UK on 5 May 2008 at 15:04 UAE time

Where is Mohammad El-Erian? Surely, he should be on the list given that he is the CO-CEO and CO-CIO of PIMCO (manages over 700 billion in assets) and was also most recently Harvard's endownment manager. Surely. this person has influence globally much more so than the many entertainers on this list!
Entertainers!!
Posted by Mohammed Saeed Harib on 22 April 2008 at 03:35 UAE time

I have been selected as one of this year's lucky (or unlucky depends how you look at it) power 100 list at 33

I am deeply saddened that many here view people in entertainment such as myself as low beings with nothing to give and with no work to be proud of. Entertainment does not only cover those dancers and singers you see and complain about (but watch anyway) it also covers formidable news presenters and even media moguls who shape what you see and believe whether you like it or not. Yes, there are many bad examples out there that we can point our fingers at but i feel personally honored that i was selected for my work as a director of a show that helped preserve our culture and identity, offering a safe alternative for viewers and their kids.

The success of FREEJ had a great influence on millions of viewers across the GCC and helped many youth get inspired and follow their dreams and it helped people in the UAE reconnect with their cultural values and the simpler life that once was.

I hate to see my team's achievements undermined just for the fact that we are in the entertainment business. Influence does not know a gender or a race or even a field for that matter. I appreciate it if such naysayers get educated about what entertainment stands for and the effects it has on our lives and our children's. We are on the bottom of the global list because we don't have a proper representation in media and because our media viewers lack the understanding of such a field.
Really???
Posted by Wael DC, Dubai, UAE on 22 April 2008 at 01:20 UAE time

Since When is Fairuz less powerful than Elissa, Antoine Choeiry, Nadine Labaki, or Amr Diab.

I had some respect for Arabian Business...not anymore. This list and the entire poll is funded by Al Waleed who unlike the REAL powerful Saudis who maintain a low profile cannot sleep if he's not on a cover of a magazine or topping a list similar to this.

Stop abusing the kindness of Arabs... They will one day bite back ;)
Voting for the so called most powerful men
Posted by Chinkiz Khan, Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan on 20 April 2008 at 12:49 UAE time

I can only picture how these polls are faked just as everything else in the Gulf and the Middle East....I think just calling these people the most powerful is ridiculous because the power that you think they possess is not defined.
Great Achievement
Posted by Murtaza Adenwala, Toronto, Canada on 17 April 2008 at 23:38 UAE time

Congratulation to Mr Sayed Ibrahim Mohammed Hussain Sharaf and the whole Sharaf Family

I was a part of Sharaf Group before migrating to Canada. Mr Sharaf has a par excellence vision, and achieves the set target/goal no matter what.

He along with the entire group has grown with time and this achievement is the testimony from shipping to retail, from IT to travel, from distribution to manufacturing and sky is the limit.
Power 100
Posted by A. Ali on 17 April 2008 at 20:19 UAE time

Your list is unrealistic as it does not reflect the true rags to riches down to earth achievers. Your top 10 are all either inheritors of a fortune (1) and expanded on it or made by the system (3,6,10). Their claim to fame is work done by others and they get the glory as they are the so called 'the Kodak Moment Photo Perfect' candidates.
H.E. Mohamed Alabbar
Posted by Brian, Dubai, U.A.E on 15 April 2008 at 11:58 UAE time

I congratulate all the individuals on the list. However, I think H.E. Mohamed Alabbar, with the guidance of H.H. Sheikh Mohamed, has accomplishments that far supercede some individuals ranked above him, and thus, he should definitely have been placed within the top 3.

May Allah bless all.
Commitment & Hard-work
Posted by amjad ayaz, dubai, uae on 13 April 2008 at 21:37 UAE time

The people on the list,,, are those who have done a great job for themselves & for the nation,, i do come from an asian country but been educated & raised in UAE i have seen it all!! apart from the people from media & entertainment!!! Its ARABIAN BUSSINESS we are not supporting here from the so called celebrity world its pure bussiness.. But once again its thanks to the people from the Team of Arabian Bussiness for this good work keep up the good work & keep us informed of M.EAST & GCC countries... Thanks & Keep it up
use money for the power of our nation
Posted by Dr. Mohamed AbdelWahab, AbuDhabi&OlandoUSA, UAE & USA on 12 April 2008 at 12:56 UAE time

They think their money in POWER. But it is not. If they use it for power it will be. But they use it for weekness through personal ego. Please let them learn about nationalisitic ego ( alqawm) they are responsible, because they posses the power of money Dr Mohamed AbdelWahab, drmwahab@hotmail.com
Who Cares??!!??!!
Posted by Grow Up!!!, Dubai, U.A.E. on 12 April 2008 at 12:02 UAE time

Its just a survey like any other... But, try not to make it a big issue and use this platform to attack any nation or group or religion... Its just a survey! Who believes ANY survey done in the World (specially in the Middle East??!!!) & (Specially in the Arab world??)? Just read the list and move on. Why do you have to judge people and bad mouth whomever is in the list? Why? Complexes drive you? And PLEASE stop relaying things to Iraq, Ghaza, Lebanon, ... We are a 300,000.000 people nation and have the right to have some fun too (When we have to fight we do it) but its useless to keep talking about the M.E. conflicts non stop. Live and Let Live. And if you don't like the article (although it didn't offend anybody), just don't read it and MOVE ON. AND YES, Al Waleed Bin Talal is a GREAT Man, so is Michel Obeid and Dr Sultan Bin Sulayem.
Shame on the editor.
Posted by Press Skeptic, Beirut, Lebanon on 11 April 2008 at 19:08 UAE time

What I thought was interesting was the lack of any representation of any clergy of any kind. I don't know if that is just a subject that the media tries to avoid to prevent blow back and negative response? Or is just that the clergy does not have the influence it once did? If the former, which I believe is more likley, then the subtext of the story is just as interesting about the nature of the media over there. On the one hand they report that flashy, flesh baring women in the entertainment industry are influential Arabs, but on the other hand are complying with the clerical influence that they are not even covering. The clergy has an overarching influence that cant be discussed. There is a freedom to report on the questionable but influential peddling of sexiness, that generates a lot of conservative criticism, (see the comments posed by readers), but there is no freedom to put the spotlight on the clerics who fuel the conservative agenda and hegemony. I think it is a twisted and confusing story on the nature of taboo in the Arab world. The confusion in my view deeply penetrates the Arab psyche. The press can report matters that are only skin deep, like sex, money, business, but when it comes to the agenda that defines the parameters of that reporting, there is no coverage. Id even call that confusion a psychosis on a mass scale. The Arab press is far from free. No matter how much sex, money and power they cover to suggest that they share values with the West, the fact is, whatever the Western style value aspirations they may want to suggest they have, its all smoke and mirrors and there is a man behind the curtain. To taunt the public with sex/power and foster public debate about it is to feign freedom because what is taken away is the ability to debate the untouchable royal/clerical hegemony.

" *The Arabian Business Power List deliberately does not include royalty, religious leaders or politicians, with the exception of HRH Prince Alwaleed who we believe should be on the list purely for his business achievements."- http://www.arabianbusiness.com/power100/feature/514974-power-and-desire-make-good-reading
No one from Oman...
Posted by Mohammad Shahnawaz on 11 April 2008 at 17:34 UAE time

I don't find anyone in the list from Oman. Is Oman was excluded from the poll or no one deserve?
Michel OBEID
Posted by Michel kassoune, Paris, France on 11 April 2008 at 02:55 UAE time

In order to clarify what Marc say, Dr. Michel OBEID had defended his thesis in Paris in December 2007.
The Power 100, 2008
Posted by mimi, kuwait, kuwait on 9 April 2008 at 19:02 UAE time

thats not fair it shoud be like this 1-nawal el zoughbi
2-haifa wehbe 3-sofia marikh 4-amal hijazy
5-nancy ajram
WELL DONE:
Posted by RAJENDRA ANEJA, DUBAI, UAE on 9 April 2008 at 17:14 UAE time

Congratulations to all the Arab 100 achievers. Particularly Sheikh Mohammad, PM of UAE and HRH Al waleed of KSA. Both of you have shown that it is possible to achieve your dreams, provided there is will, endeavour and determination.
CONGRATS
Posted by Ummu Kusum Salley, Lago, Nigeria on 9 April 2008 at 15:18 UAE time

To say that you have accomplished so much at such a young age,you have made me realize that the sky is only the beginning.
The Power 100, 2008
Posted by Mohammed Arshad Hasan, Dubai, UAE on 7 April 2008 at 10:55 UAE time

Congratulations to all Dubai World employees as our Chairman H.E. Sultan Ahmed Bin Sulayem Ranked No -1 in UAE and No - 3 in Arab world. Mr. Sulayem is a visionary and a charismatic leader.
Congratulations to Joseph Ghassoub - Well deserved !
Posted by George Abi Nakad, New York, USA on 6 April 2008 at 20:14 UAE time

As a fellow Lebanese citizen living abroad and an old family friend to the Ghassoubs', my wife and I like to offer our congratulations to Joseph on his achievemnts including the latest award being offered to him this weekend in Washington DC; The first Dubai Lynx Advertising Person of the Year Award.
My negative pessimistic nation
Posted by Malaz, Dubai, UAE on 6 April 2008 at 13:05 UAE time

whenever there's a place for my nation to speak out something, to post an opinion or a comment, they turn into gloomay tragic thinkers and philosophers.
They mention palestine and iraq, warriors & martyrs, the slaughtered moms & orphan kids. Can't we have a break?
Well, yes, amr diab and elissa are in the top 100, why not? I don't like the theme of their songs which i find shallow, but they did have an impact on various generations. Whether the influnce was arguably good or bad, opinions vary, but the fact is they work in the entertainment field & gained their fame. The same applies to everybody in the list, each has succeeded in a way or another.

Life is not only about serious issues, we kill, we fight, we destroy, that's what made our modern life the way it is now, and we do need a space to enjoy it as the price was too high.
Dimwits
Posted by Rashed Al Amiri, Sharjah, UAE on 5 April 2008 at 18:54 UAE time

Well it's sad to see people like Nadine Libky and other pop stars who are worth nothing in society and do nothing but expose their bodies and in the end gain more recognition than hard working employee's like myself and yourselves.

It's also a shame that a fashion primadonna like Ellie Saab gets recognized just because he pleases the western world and is an Arab male with feminine touch while people like you and I, commoners, work around the clock and let our actions, not tv or magazines, speak for us.

It is even a more shame when a non-self made man, who has all the doors opened to him and has the privileges of the ruling party in Saudi Arabia like Prince Al Waleed gets recognized over and over. Of course, not mentioning the media power behind the latter.

It is a sad sad truth. What is common is that all above mentioned have been in one way or the other been prompted or recognized or pushed by the Lebanese media power brokers.

Seriously, get a life. I wont let an article or a magazine decide for me who's who.

In my views, any small kid making his way in Palestine is more powerful than any Arab on this list.
Influence
Posted by Iyad, Dubai, UAE on 3 April 2008 at 08:21 UAE time

What influence those top 100 have to make the difference in Iraq and Palestine? What influence do they have to make the difference towards democracy!?

I have respect to some of the names mentioned on this list, respect for their achievement but I do not see them as the most influential 100 Arabs.
open ur eyes and dont give people more than what they really worth.
Posted by Ala, Dubai, UAE on 2 April 2008 at 13:10 UAE time

I am happy that we all Arabs have an ability to communicate both important and "trivial things" I think nationality should not be something we fight about - we are all Arabs.
Our energy is going to the wrong direction. I am a Palestinian-Jordanian lady married to a German man. There are a lot of other things which define whether a person is powerful or not, and you can distinguish the strong people from the weak by looking back to history how he or she built him/herself.

I think a powerful man is someone who has built himself and his success from the zero without help without money - through his brain, energy and commitment. The same goes for the powerful ladies who can use their wisdom instead of their "femininity" to reach to the top!

After all, guys think deeper and think right. Incidentally I am proud of the son of my country, Wadah Khanfar :)
No need for brains !
Posted by Critic, Dubai on 2 April 2008 at 11:50 UAE time

I've noticed that all influential Arabs from Lebanon are in the entertainment business, because it doesn't really need brains to be able to sing and dance ! I respect the other influential Arabs who "used their brains" to make it to this list, i.e. people in the other industries ! It's so sad to see the legendary Magdi Yacoub comes in after Elissa and Nancy Ajram !!!
harsh truth
Posted by Ibrahim, Amman, Jordan on 1 April 2008 at 15:22 UAE time

I think listing people in the "so called media field" is a tragedy.
Please try to focus on real art and talent instead of listing trash artist and making them Arab's elite.
Despite of everything, I think this list is true , that’s why we (Arabs) will stay in the bottom of all bottoms.
The good, the bad and the ugly!
Posted by Firas Murad, Dubai, UAE on 1 April 2008 at 09:24 UAE time

I really enjoyed reading the list and although I disagreed with some I agree with many others. In general it was a fun read!

Here is my take on the good, the bad and the ugly!

The good, is that this year list is getting more diversified so I am very happy to see science, art and culture appearing more on the list. I hope these segment get more influence in our lives!

The bad, so logic in the list does not make sense at all. Sameer Alansari, the head of one of the smallest subsidiaries in Dubai Holding, makes the list at number 11 and no other executive chairman from the large subsidiaries make the list!

The ugly, well, nothing really ugly, but with Amer Diab at 24, I must be living in a different Arab world!

Also seeing the influence of the advertising dollar in the list is obvious!
Lebanese Orientation
Posted by Wasiullah, Kuwait, Kuwait on 1 April 2008 at 00:01 UAE time

This list is understandably leb-leaning, as is most of the Media in the Arab World. But surely a TV face making it to the list, without much to add to, is a simple slap on the wrist. I guess you could be a bit more objective. But no sweat! There's always the next year.
When we become objective...
Posted by Youmna on 31 March 2008 at 22:50 UAE time

Hi "Influential", if you could for a moment forget POLITICS, you'd become aware of the fact that Arabian Business is written by British editors, even the Arabic version does not have any Lebanese editor.
So live with the fact that Lebanese people are among the most 100 influential Arabs!
funny list
Posted by Al-Iraqi, abu dhabi, uae on 31 March 2008 at 21:10 UAE time

If Kadhem As Saher is not there, I can't trust this list.
Unfair
Posted by Abdul Aziz, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates on 31 March 2008 at 20:37 UAE time

AMNA BIN HINDI supposed to be in the first 10 positions on the world's most powerful Arabs.

92 is UNFAIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIR!
What a influence...
Posted by Syed R Shah, Doha, Qatar on 31 March 2008 at 18:41 UAE time

I am amazed to see how many people are concerned on your Power 100 - 2008 list (You definitely have made a statement). I am confident the list has been made by qualified judges and they will surely have their reasons but aren’t we are in 21st centaury where democracy plays a major role. In my opinion you should have asked for public votes in each category and then your (qualified) judges could compile them in a single list by number of votes. ..…Its normal people who have given the Power, hence it’s their right!

Editors' reply An excellent idea - one one that we will look into for next year as a component of how we choose the Power List. For this year what we will do is put the top 20 up for a reader vote, and based on your choices, compile an ArabianBusiness.com reader list of who our audience think are the most powerful Arabs in the region. Look for a new poll later on today.
Proud of Amna Binhendi
Posted by Um M7md, dxb, uae on 31 March 2008 at 18:40 UAE time

Amna Binhendi a young lady who is following the footsteps of her well known father Mr Binhendi. She is a very strong yet simple character...She has added to the successes of UAE ladies and has given the impression to the world that women in the Arabic region are as equally important as men and are responsible for a lot of successful events in the business field. Because of her young age and large status as a CEO she has gained a lot of attention from the media lately... As an emirati I am very proud of Amna Binhendi and wish her the very best. I also wish all the young ladies to follow her footstep, in working hard and taking part in the success of their country, the UAE, in different fields.
Insufficient research
Posted by P B, London, UK on 31 March 2008 at 18:30 UAE time

Would just like to point out to a few flaws resulting from the (lack of) research done before writing this article:

You've replied to Ashraf Al-Hassan by saying that royalty and politicians were left out and yet Prince Waleed tops the list. Another thing related to him is that he isn't the RICHEST ARAB! Sheikh Khalifa (Prime Minister of Bahrain) is!

Prince Waleed confessed this himself in an interview with CNN last year where he mentioned the fact that Sheikh Khalifa of Bahrain has much more wealth than he.

Also, Sheikha Haya Al-Khalifa (also of Bahrain) should have been included in the 2008 lists of the Most Influential Arabs and the Most Influential Arab Women. The reason being, she was elected President of the 61st UN General Assembly and she even asked President Bush to get his act together (in a much nicer way of course).

How many people (regardless of gender) would you find in today's time to be able to talk like that to the President of the USA, in public, and yet get away with it?!

In case you'd like to get a head start with your research then here's a little link on Sheikha Haya which might be useful:
http://www.un.org/ga/president/61/presskit/president.shtml

By the way, I'm not Bahraini, in case you're wondering, in fact I'm not even Arab.

Hopefully, next time on you won't publish politically incorrect and offensive articles.

Thank you for your time!


Editors reply You make a great case, and that is a lovely story. However as we said, we do exclude royalty and politicians except when their influence comes from their business interests.
Road safety? Are you kidding?
Posted by jimmynostrils on 31 March 2008 at 18:16 UAE time

In reference to Omar - should there actually be a "road safety specialist" resident in Dubai, he or she might want to rethink their job. When they gather enough influence to make my journey home a little less harrowing, we can talk about a mention on the 'Power 100'.
A magical list
Posted by Haifa, Dubai, United Arab Emirates on 31 March 2008 at 17:55 UAE time

Personally I think this is a wonderful list that shows the diversity and range of talents that the Arab world has to offer. We do not need another list of clones in business suits. What we need is a list that reflects what the Arab world in general brings to the world - what art brings to the world, singers bring to the world, women - like me! - bring to the world, as well as business people in business suits making money.

I loved reading this list. It gave me encouragement that Arab civilization is flourishing across the boardrooms - and beyond. That's a sign of a civilization that is growing, developing, deepening. It's something we should all be immeasurably proud of.

Incidentally I am from the UAE. I am not Lebanese
Narrow Minded & Unqualified List
Posted by Susan Schuster Zaidan, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia on 31 March 2008 at 17:44 UAE time

Very poor background research done on compiling this list. The Saudi women on the list are minimal. Does writing a mediocre novel qualify a person to this list? Your criteria for selection is biased & poor. You have missed a whole segment of self made Saudi women & women who have philanthropic "power" in the KSA.
I do not believe it
Posted by ?????????? on 31 March 2008 at 17:36 UAE time

We have many influential people in the Arab world who deserve our recognition rather than Elissa or people like her. There are many Academians, writers and scholars deserve to be in the list here!!!!

Ismail from UAE you are absolutely right.. thank you
influential
Posted by Ghassan, Dubai, UAE on 31 March 2008 at 17:09 UAE time

I am writing this comment while I am almost sure that you are not going to publish it, I have discussed your list with number of truly influential men and women in the Media, business ,entertainment and sport industry and the conclusion is;

a) The list, mainly in terms of ranking, and partly in terms of the chosen names lacks the minimum acceptable limit of rationality.
b) It is so obvious that it is constructed by a Lebanese who supports a certain particular movement in Lebanon.
c) The professionalism of the list writer (s) is very much under question and thus it highly affects the credibility of the institution he or she or they work for.
d) The comments that you have received so far from proves the solidity of each of the above three points.

Hope to receive a reasonable comment form the editor if and when this comment will be approved suitable for publishing by your concerned authority.
Alert
Posted by Hassan, RIyadh, KSA on 31 March 2008 at 16:49 UAE time

The largest oil producing country has few powerful Arabs. I hope you get it that Saudi Arabia should have had more powerful Arabs... and this is very unfortunate . What do we lack?
This list reflects the level of our journalists!
Posted by omar, Dubai, UAE on 31 March 2008 at 15:46 UAE time

What a list! No scientist? No human rights activist? No road safety specialist? Sadly this list reflects the level of our journalists! I do not respect 80% of the names listed although I closely work for one of the top 10 names and i personally know many others shown in the list! I believe you fundamentally need to develop your HR dept. in order to get highly qualified journalists before you publish such a report! I also like to say that the list is a deep disrespect for our females & their capabilities.
World Most influential Arabs
Posted by Ashraf Al-Hassan, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia on 31 March 2008 at 15:10 UAE time

Thank you for your logical special report, and thank you for your efforts as usual, but I have a small Q? please I need to understand your report basically based on what? (World Most influential Arabs), what I mean I don’t see a political person with your list...

Editors Reply You won't see a political person on this list, because we do not include royalty or politicians - save where they have strong business interests that make them influential.

We measure power simply as the ability to influence. Some have this through their businesses, some through charisma, some through the media they can direct. The list is our view of who, at this time, has the ability to make others listen, to change their perceptions of the world. Everyone on the list has this ability. Everyone on the list can be compared in this way.

Some people on this list will find their power ephemeral or short lived. Others, especially those for whom their power is institutionalised in a position, will probably be in next year's list, and the year after... But everyone on the 2008 Power 100 has, in this moment here and now, the ability to make the Arab world sit up and listen
Too many entertainers
Posted by Suhail Ahmed, Dubai, UAE on 31 March 2008 at 13:50 UAE time

Way too many entertainers make up the list, moreover second spot for Iraqi footballer is not justifiable. We would like to see those people who can shape the world around them!
Marcel Khalife
Posted by Zaher, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates on 31 March 2008 at 13:39 UAE time

Marcel is actually Lebanese, not Palestinian. He has never been to Palestine. He is from a small town in Lebanon called Amsheet. Please correct your entry.
What do you mean by influential?
Posted by Maha, Dubai, UAE on 31 March 2008 at 13:23 UAE time

You mentioned above that you measure it by the "power to influence". How? I'd say, as an example, that Amr Khalid, Yousif Al Qaradhawi, Abdul-Baari Atwaan are pretty influential yet I don't see them on the list while I see Younis Mahmoud given waaaaaaaaay more credit than he deserves (I'm Iraqi by the way and have 3 football fanatics in the house; I know to what extent Younis' influence is). Younis made some young Iraqis quite happy for a few days… that’s it, and then they all went back to fighting. Abdul-Baari Atwaan, on the other hand, influences thousands of Arabs by his inflammatory interviews on Al Jazeer or editorials in his newspaper, Amr Khalid changed the definition of religion to the upper crust youth of the Arab World (I hate the guy, but there is no denying his influence) and Yousif al Qaradhawi, is, well, ask Waddah Khanfar.

Not only money is influence. Money helps, I mean what is Al Faed without money, but it’s not the only qualification for influence. If you really, really think that Younis Mahmoud is more influential than Al Qaradawi or even Al Sistaani, then you must have a totally different definition of “influential” than most people understand.
Just respect our minds
Posted by Guss, Manama, Bahrain on 31 March 2008 at 13:19 UAE time

I am so much amazed at this list. Nadine Labki has influence more than any Arab woman? This is could be only true if you only and only make your survey in nightclubs... I think Queen Rania in Jordan has more influence. Your survey is quite biased to the Lebanese and promotes amateurs like Nadine, Younes and Alissa. Your major criteria seems to be 1- Lebanese or related to them; 2- Entertainers more than professionals. Presuming that your selected sample is only conducting tiny solid slice that could be teenagers, or those with the same mentality.
Is this list acceptable in Yomul Qiyamah!
Posted by Ismail, Kuwait, Kuwait on 31 March 2008 at 13:07 UAE time

This could be a list based on subjective judgment and various criteria. I have following comments to make :

1. How many from this list earned their money from non Islamic means (interest, liquor, cheating, horse racing, casinos, gambling, unfair advantages...) ?
2. How many of this used bribe and finacial corruption to gain undue advantages against rivals ?
3. How many of this are thanking Allah or this blessings?
4. How many of this list are paying proper Zakat for legal earning?
5. How many in this list take care of his/her employees?
6. How many of in this list pay taxes?
7. How many of this list achived this at he expesnse of family and personal life.

I would like to remind myself and all in the list and all in general
that you cannot move one step forward in youmul qiyamah ( day of judgment) without answering how did you earn and how did you spent your wealth.

REMEBER THE DAY! ALL THIS LIFE IS JUST ILLUSION!

May Allah guide all of us to right path.

Ismail.
POWER 100
Posted by mir taqui ali, Jeddah, KSA on 31 March 2008 at 12:46 UAE time

You have pictures of 3 ladies on the cover of Power 100. One is Elissa, 2nd is Nadine Labaki, Who is the 3rd.....
Thanks...

Editors reply Her name is Raja Al Sanea, the author of Girls of Riyadh. You can access the full list and her profile from the special report itself - www.arabianbusiness.com/power100. Raja makes it to number 77 on the list.
Flawed Arab List
Posted by Hayder Rasheed on 31 March 2008 at 11:50 UAE time

When you miss academics, researchers and inventors on the account of singers, you know that the standard and the criterion is flawed.
comments on the egyptians on this list
Posted by haitham Ragb, jeddah, ksa on 31 March 2008 at 11:06 UAE time

I find this list logical and realistic. I do have a comment on Egyptian list. Egypt still has an important role in changing Arab world. Egypt has 10 representatives on the list - 10% of the total. We have 3 scientists in medicine, the nuclear field and at NASA (the best); 4 in media and entertainment (the most famous even than the previous); 1 in sports (the fastest spreading); 2 very rich businessmen - one abroad and the other is worldwide in and out (the most effective). I hope the list increases in science and media (and not singers and actors only).

The only omission I can see is Dr Ahmed Zeoul (a scientist). I wish the best of luck for all Arabs...
Prince Alwaleed tops Power 100
Posted by Nasrin Quraishi, Chennai, India on 31 March 2008 at 10:50 UAE time

'You don’t teach a man just how to eat a fish. You have to teach him how to fish then eat the fish'. Some countries can’t afford to teach everyone. My strategy is to feed them the fish until they are able to fish, and then they go fishing."

If everybody understands & realise this, we will definitely cut off the word "HUNGER & POVERTY" from the dictionary.

Hats off to Prince Alwaleed.
Entertainers
Posted by Andrew, Doha, Qatar on 31 March 2008 at 10:16 UAE time

Were you running short of people so you made up the shortfall with entertainers and a football player?

Look at how many of the entertainers from last year held on to their positions of power. If you are only 'powerful' for a period of about 12 months, I would argue you aren't really powerful at all.
Hi
Posted by Manoj, Dubai, United Arab Emirates on 31 March 2008 at 10:06 UAE time

I am new to the UAE, but know the values of this country, it is the most important country which has grown in a very short period of time. The 100 names are important and need to be respected as they are the ones behind the rapid growth of the UAE Economy.
Good Work
Posted by Syed Sameer, Dubai, U A E on 31 March 2008 at 09:31 UAE time

I do feel that some powerful names are missing from the so called Power 100 but still do believe that the compilation is very good. The most surprising aspect is the power of entertainment industry over business houses and I feel the credibility of this compilation takes the back seat at this point. Anyway good work.. I am really proud to note the names of Amna Bin Hendi, Ibrahim Sharaf, Khaldoon Mubarak, Ahmed Ali Al Sayegh, Sultan Nasser Al Suweidi and feel that these names will catch up with others at the top in the coming years.
Definitely 10/10
Posted by omar malik, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates on 31 March 2008 at 08:37 UAE time

Excellent compilation. I may disagree at some rankings but overall the list is near to perfection. Congratulation to the team for a good job.

Would love to get a hard copy of the magazine for my library. Is it possible?

Editors' reply Yes, of course - just go to any supermarket or book shop and buy the latest copy of Arabian Business - on the shelves now...
Prince AlWaleed
Posted by Gulbar, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates on 31 March 2008 at 02:52 UAE time

I'm impressed on busy days of HRH Prince AlWaleed and admire of his lifestyle, responsibility and helping people! He is really blessed by God. & understand deeply his feeling of serenity and finding peace and closeness to roots by being at desert!
Nadine Labaki vs Sheikh Ahmed
Posted by David Paul, Dubai, UAE on 31 March 2008 at 00:55 UAE time

How does Nadine Labaki have more power than Sheikh Ahmed bin Saeed? One hit film versus 20-odd years of building an airline that could buy out any European carrier? Granted the arts are powerful, but if Emirates were to only buy Embraer jets tomorrow, you can guarantee governments in Europe would be very unhappy. I can't imagine Labaki with the same power, even if she decided she wanted to make her next film in Zimbabwe.

He's quieter and less glamourous too, but you are basically saying filmmakers have more power than businessmen? You cannot compare the two, each is influential for a very different reason. That's why Forbes and Fortune run separate entertainment lists.

Editors Reply We measure power simply as the ability to influence. Some have this through their businesses, some through charisma, some through the media they can direct. The list is our view of who, at this time, has the ability to make others listen, to change their perceptions of the world. Everyone on the list has this ability. Everyone on the list can be compared in this way.
heart to heart
Posted by jimmynostrils on 30 March 2008 at 23:43 UAE time

Steam cells? Sounds like a lot of hot air to me:

Most recently the professor led a team at the heart science centre at Harefield hospital in being the first to grow a human heart from steam cells.
Top 100 Arabs
Posted by Mike roberts, london, UK on 30 March 2008 at 22:57 UAE time

How do you verify what some of these powerful people are really worth as a lot are closed and secretive family businesses? How do you justify excluding someone like Abdullatif Jameel, a great philanthropist and believer in empowering the poorest while maintaining a low profile, and yet include some who do not pay their employees on time as being the richest, etc? While some undoubtedly deserve to be on the list, it speaks volumes that so few academics and thinkers are on the list... This illustrates the poverty of current Arab obsession with money and shallowness and not creativity through intellectual contribution .. In the UK Hawkins would be way up in the list...
Bahrain's list not complete
Posted by Haseeb, Manama, Bahrain on 30 March 2008 at 21:46 UAE time

I believe list looks incomplete without considering the King or PM of Bahrain. Since they have been most powerful reformist in the kingdom

Or is it because , the compiler has purposefully ignore the Rulers and PMs?

Editors reply Yes, we purposely ignore royaly and politicians - except when they have strong business interests, and then their inclusion is a measure of that...
The Great Arabs !
Posted by ajit, tripoli, libya on 30 March 2008 at 21:03 UAE time

Its really a very good compilation, which shows us the achievements and contribution of the Arabs in the development of the region and the world at large!
Younes Mahmoud
Posted by Muhaned, dubai, uae on 30 March 2008 at 20:16 UAE time

Iraqis are proud of Younes Mahmoud.
List
Posted by Hassan, Dubai, UAE on 30 March 2008 at 17:50 UAE time

It is ridiculous to think that a singer like Elissa and Amr Diab are more powerfull of such people as Saleh Kamel or his like.
This takes away all the credibility of this exercise.
Excellent compilation
Posted by Arshed, Dubai, UAE on 30 March 2008 at 17:15 UAE time

Not only does it give you an insight into the progress and the wealth being generated in this region but it also frightens you to know that the disparity in the welath is widening at formula 1 pace between the haave's and the strugglers.
On a lighter note, this also gives me a great opportunity to have a good database for my corporate sales & pitches. Thanks very much to Arabian Gulf Business team. 3 Cheers.
The Winning Spirits and attitiudes among arabs.
Posted by Fadi El-Agha, Dubai, U.A.E on 30 March 2008 at 15:53 UAE time

First and foremost, Mabrook to all the top succesors for this glorious year 2008. I'm assured and positive that this success derives from winning habits and actions done by these great leaders and innovators from this region in the arab world. I and all of us are truly proud and encouraged from all the achievments the BUSINESS POWER TOP 100 have fullfilled. Thank you limitlessly, Arabian Business.com to embrace this kind of media interaction with us the audience and to share all our glorius success.
100 powerful people in the arab world
Posted by ajit, dubai, uae on 30 March 2008 at 15:15 UAE time

While this does make interesting reading, i must add that this list is not reflective of the real scenario. You must spread your net wider to collect genuine information as most of the people that you write about are just business men and have no power in any way to change the life of people around them or are proxy power to the real powers. I am sure you get the drift of what i intend to write.
Abdul Aziz Al Ghurair
Posted by Srinivasan, Dubai, UAE on 30 March 2008 at 14:53 UAE time

Abdul Aziz Al ghurair has come down by 32 levels is really saddening as he has added one more feather in his cap as the speaker. Unfortunately the banking has not done up to the expectation especially in the front office services. It is not only changing the logo..., but it has to definitely improve its services dramatically. Hope next year my favourite bank will push its CEO to regain the glory of earlier years.
Great People
Posted by Javid, Kuwait City, Kuwait on 30 March 2008 at 14:40 UAE time

Mashaallah,

I salute to these great people who contributed their time,efforts to make strong GCC & arab economic hub.

May Allah bless all of them .

Regards
JAvid Ur Rahaman Shaik
Congrats
Posted by Srinivasan, Dubai, UAE on 30 March 2008 at 14:38 UAE time

Congrats foremost to Arabian.com for bringing the list. Hope you keep up your efforts and one day you would be named as one of the most powerful media moghul.
Congratulations!
Posted by Riad Andari, Falougha, Lebanon on 30 March 2008 at 14:26 UAE time

Congratulations to the creative class on the list.
Congratulations to Prince alwaleed bin Talal and Kingdom Holdings.
Congratulations to H.H. Sheikh Tahnoon bin Zayed Al Nahyan, the Royal Group and Hydra Properties.
Congratulations to H.H. Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashed Al Maktoum, Dubai Holdings, Emaar and Nakheel.
POWER MOST 100
Posted by MUKRI ISHRAT ANJUM, DOHA, QATAR on 30 March 2008 at 14:23 UAE time

This is good job by Arabian news.
We appreiciate the same.

Any one from Qatar ?
Power 100 list
Posted by John, Bahrain on 30 March 2008 at 14:00 UAE time

I'm just curious to note that HH Sh. Khalifa Bin Sulman Al Khalifa, the Bahrain Prime Minister is not listed on the Power 100. Since he's been the Bahraini PM for decades, I would be very surprised if he had not accumulated the required amount of dosh needed to make it onto the list. Or is it that he has moved it around so the compilers don't know how much he has?
Power 100
Posted by zen on 30 March 2008 at 12:43 UAE time

What about the Al Futtaim family of Dubai?
Brilliant article
Posted by Frank, Dubai, United Arab Emirates on 30 March 2008 at 11:42 UAE time

A brilliant, eclectic article. I loved the richness and diversity of your choices. Another inspiring ArabianBusiness.com article.
Marcel Khalife
Posted by Marc, Paris on 30 March 2008 at 09:40 UAE time

Marcel Khalife is Lebanese and not Palestinian (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marcel_Khalife)
Michel Obeid
Posted by Marc, Paris on 30 March 2008 at 09:28 UAE time

This is just to clarify that Michel Obeid is not a doctor yet (he didn't submit his thesis as of yet) so it would be better not to put Dr. as a prefix. Nonetheless, the discovery he made already is amazing.
Power 100 List
Posted by Lee, Dubai, UAE on 30 March 2008 at 09:27 UAE time

In your article you state there is only 1 member of royalty included but I believe there are a total of 3.....
Power 100 List
Posted by Lee, Dubai, UAE on 30 March 2008 at 09:25 UAE time

How can you include Amna Bin Hendi but exclude her father, Mohi Din Bin Hendi? He created Bin Hendi Enterprises from nothing. If she is in the top 100 then he should also be on the list.
another test
Posted by Walid, Dubai, United Arab Emirates on 27 March 2008 at 15:51 UAE time

this special report is really good, go on arabianbusiness.com