Islamic finance sector 'in danger'

The Islamic finance sector is in danger because both banks and Sharia scholars are not providing solutions which are Sharia-based, a senior Islamic finance expert warned on Tuesday.

"I believe that the Islamic finance sector is in danger," said Abdulazeem Abozaid, member of the Sharia department in UAE-based Emirates Islamic Bank, in an exclusive interview with ArabianBusiness.com.

"The banks have just one aim - to maximise profits. They know that there is no real difference between conventional banking and Islamic finance," Abozaid said, speaking at the International Islamic Finance Forum (IIFF) in Dubai.

"As for the Sharia scholars, then they have become corrupted. The ones who the banks seek are those who will be more flexible with their judgments, not those who are more strict."

A paradigm shift from Sharia compliance in the Islamic finance sector to basing banking on Sharia principles is one of the main themes of this year's IIFF.

Abozaid said that it will be consumers themselves who will demand that the Islamic finance sector reforms itself to meet the obligations of being "Islamic".

"We have to change - the industry will be pushed towards changing by the public, not by the banks or by the Sharia scholars," said Abozaid.

"When they see the controversies in the industry, they will demand that the products that are given are genuinely Islamic."

According to Thomson Financial, Islamic finance assets are growing at an annual pace of 20% and are set to hit $2 trillion in 2010 from the current $900 billion.

In a panel discussion about the future of Islamic finance, Rushdie Siddiqui, global director of Dow Jones Islamic Indexes, said he disagreed with the sentiment about doom-and-gloom for the sector.

“We are where we are supposed to be,” said Siddiqui, who set up the first Islamic index on Dow Jones in 1999. “You’ve seen a number of things stick and number of things exit."

In the short term, there were debates which are matter of time and those which will always be a source of controversy, Siddiqui added.

“We will always have a debate on halal [lawful in Islam] and haram [unlawful],” he said. “As for questions of standardisation and Sharia boards, then these are a function of time.”

Siddiqui also outlined what he believed are five “bottlenecks” which the Islamic finance sector has and which need to be resolved.

“We will always talk about Libor- i.e. why isn’t there an Islamic Libor," said Siddiqui, referring to the London Internbank Offered Rate, which refers to interest rates at which banks lend funds between each other on the London money markets.

The second issue outlined was on the human assets side, where women were not being utilised in the Islamic finance industry and which needed to be addressed.

Media communications surrounding the sector has also been inadequate, with both journalists and investors relations departments to blame, Siddiqui said.

“Islamic finance is much bigger than just being against interest in pork [as stated in most media],” Siddiqui said. “We have to better communicate what Islamic finance really is - in this regard, the financial journalism is just not there and investor relations at Islamic banks have frankly failed.”

There was also a need to discern stakeholders in the industry, who were not fully participating or being ignored, he added.

“We need to look at who the stakeholders are - regulators, central banks, Islamic banks and standard-setting boards like AAOIFI (Accounting and Auditing Organization for Islamic Financial Institutions) - and how they can work together,” he said.

“The final issue is consolidation, which the central banks have to encourage,” said Siddiqui. “If you want to do the bigger deals it is going to have to happen.”

Print | Email | Discuss this article

| Share |

READERS' COMMENTS

The permissibility issue
Posted by The Mindset, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia on Sunday 18 May 2008 at 14:19 UAE time


What is permissible to a typical conventional banker is a transaction that makes money and a Sharia' scholar who either is compliant, or is narrated the transaction in a way to make it compliant. I wont want to comment on the corruption of the Sharia' scholars, since they are a better judge to it. If they dont fear making haraam halaal, then they really need to be introspect and think again. It a huge responsibility when you are making judgment on behalf of the entire nation and will be asked one day to validate its authenticity.

Islamic banks need to (as rightly commented by a brother previously) change the mindset from a profit making machine that supplants conventional profit making behemoths in finance. The spirit of Islamic finance is equitable profit so when my bank , that earns 60% from a particular transaction gives me 3% profit, there is a serious problem. The depositor needs to share the booty, and the small time tuck shop owner needs to be extended finance if the real (and desired) face of Islamic finance is to be shown to the world. There is no point hiring andrews from XYZ International Bank in London and relying on their conventional expertise to transmute C-finance to I-finance, the transmutation needs to be REAL and not a mere change in nomenclature.

These all need to change, and change fast....
Wallaho Alam Bisawaab

Old Wine in New bottle
Posted by Muhammad Saleem, Southampton, England on Tuesday 6 May 2008 at 21:46 UAE time

I am doing my research proposal on Islamic banking and financing potential in UK. For this purpose I have collected some primary and secondary data and I have semi concluded my result that strong communication is the only way to compete with conventional banking. Less advertisement, promotions and unskilled staff are hurdles in Islamic banking & financial institutions growth and because of less understanding of sharia'a banking people think that there is no difference between conventional banking and islamic banking, it is just "old wine in new bottle".

Need A Paradigm Shift of Islamic Bankers
Posted by Jhordy Kashoogie, Kuala Lumpur on Sunday 27 April 2008 at 12:16 UAE time


What shaikh Dr. Abdulazeem is really true! the bankers in the islamic banks, most of them still have conventional bank mindset because most of them are used to work in conventional banks so that they are trying to circumvent shariah principle in order to maximize the profit as much as possible without realizing they work for islamic banks, not conventional banks!. this is actually the stem of the problem.

Islamic Credit Card
Posted by Islamic Banker, Dubai, UAE on Thursday 17 April 2008 at 14:28 UAE time

What is the prospect and future of Islamic Credit Cards in UAE Market? And what are the various Islamic concepts available for developing & marketing the Shariah-compliant card?

Click here to post a comment

Add your Comment All posts are sent to the administrator for review and are published only after approval. ArabianBusiness.com reserves the right to remove any comment at any time for any reason. Please keep your responses appropriate and on topic. Arabian Business would like to point out that only comments relevant to the story will be published. Any containing personal insults or inappropriate language will not be approved.
Name *
Remember me on this computer
Email *	(Your email address will not be published)
City
Country
Subject *
Comment *
Notify me of further comments
Enter the words above *
Please click post only once - your comment will not be published immediately.

MORE FROM ARABIANBUSINESS.COM