Trust me, I have $1bn stashed in the bank

Wondering where all those Arthur Andersen accountants went? It may have been India.

It's tempting to make that mental leap amid Satyam Computer Services Ltd's book-cooking scandal. Ramalinga Raju is no longer the entrepreneur who built India's fourth-biggest software maker. He's now allegedly the nation's answer to Jeffrey Skilling, the former Enron Corp CEO serving a 24-year prison term.

Satyam's crisis may be more jaw-dropping than Enron's in 2001. It's not just the magnitude of the scam - 53,000 employees may lose jobs compared with 5000 at Enron - but the simplicity.

Enron's fraud was conducted through a labyrinth of off-balance sheet deals and other accounting gimmicks. Accounting firm Arthur Andersen approved the company's financial creativity and collapsed in 2002. Enron didn't make it easy for the auditor.

Satyam's con was impossibly transparent: The Hyderabad-based company said it had $1bn in the bank that it didn't.

Raju said he inflated earnings and assets. Assuming he's telling the truth, you would think auditor PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP or board members could have cleared up a mess years in the making with a phone call, a fax machine or even a postage stamp. Management says it has a mountain of cash in the bank and you just flat-out believe it?

And why did the World Bank appear to know more about Satyam's business practices than everyone else? Last month, the Washington-based lender declared Satyam ineligible for contracts for eight years, alleging "improper benefits" were given to the bank's employees.

If Raju's version of the story is the right one, it raises a stark question: Could a moderately sized start-up company claim to have $1bn or $2bn in cash and then go public without observers delving deeper?

Then again, Raju's claims have yet to be proven. Investigations are afoot and no one is talking publicly - no comments all around from auditors and Raju, who was arrested along with brother Rama on Jan 9.

"There can be two possibilities," says Ved Jain, president of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. "One, the auditor has been negligent. Second, he was aware and intentionally overlooked it."

The bigger question, of course, is what else is hiding below the surface in Asia's third-biggest economy. Is this "Enron moment" merely the tip of the iceberg? Or will it have a chastening effect that leaves India better off five years from now? It's impossible to know.

The days of giving corporate executives the benefit of the doubt are long gone. The shenanigans at Enron, WorldCom Inc and Parmalat SpA have even lost their shock-value following the failure of Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc and financier Bernard Madoff's alleged $50bn fraud.

Clearly, this isn't an India-specific problem. It's important to remember that India's economy and 1.2 billion people have vast potential. This is as much a setback for global corporate governance as it is for Indian officials.

Yet this is the second big blow for corporate India in recent months. It's unclear how the Mumbai terror attacks in November that left 164 people dead will affect business. The Satyam affair has only compounded concerns that foreign investors will view India less favourably.

Arun Kejriwal, founder of Kejriwal Research & Investment Services in Mumbai, spoke for many when he said: "This is a black day for India."

The reason is this scandal involves India's premier global industry. That amplifies the economic ripple effect. It's anyone's guess whether the government will heed calls for a public bailout.

Credit Suisse Group analysts Nilesh Jasani and Arya Sen advised investors in a report last week to own shares of Indian companies with "good corporate governance" as Satyam's troubles may prompt disclosure of more one-time losses. That's all well and good, yet that's what Satyam investors thought they had done.

The last decade has been disorienting for investors, especially the last 12 months. First it was regulators asleep on the job, then credit-rating companies and then accountants.

Raju, 54, was named Ernst & Young Entrepreneur of the Year in 2007. It seems he was far more entrepreneurial than regulators knew. Raju presumably also fooled Satyam's board of directors.

In a letter to the board last week, Raju could have been speaking for shareholders when he said that hiding the truth "was like riding a tiger, not knowing how to get off without being eaten.

Things just got harder for India at the worst time imaginable. Prime minister Manmohan Singh expects the economy to grow about 7 percent in the 12 months ending March 31.

Even if that rate is achieved, global trends have turned decidedly against India's prospects. Two months ago, officials in New Delhi were still saying India was less vulnerable to the global credit crisis than Asian peers. Two stimulus packages since early December, four interest rate cuts since October and Satyam's woes all belie that claim.

The risk is that recent events will reduce the foreign investment needed to maintain rapid growth and spread its benefits. India's 2009 just got a bit more precarious.

William Pesek is a Bloomberg News columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.

Print | Email | Discuss this article

| Share |

READERS' COMMENTS

Its just the typical Indian way
Posted by Suhail Akhtar on Monday 19 January 2009 at 15:22 UAE time


Well the companies should immediate should doing businnesses with India.
Satyam is just another example of how Artificial India's world of business and economy is.
Only 3 percent corrupt People are trying make the entire world fool.
I just wondered y Pakistan wasn't blamed in case of Satyam as India does in every little pinch.

Well Satyam may or not change the attutidue of India but i would definately create a Bollywood Blockbuster...

well, you say so
Posted by Deepak Melwyn on Sunday 18 January 2009 at 20:14 UAE time


I guess, author has ignored the whole mess of what has happened in the US and passed judgement of what happened to Satyam. I suspect the so called one of the BIG 4 Auditors-PriceWaterhouse is involved in this scam by intentionally hiding the facts. How on earth could $1BN be there on the balance sheet and not in the Bank? Is it not the responsibility of the auditor to check the same. I suppose as compared to US banks Indian banks are much stronger since they have good central bank as a regulator. Satyam was a good example of worse corporate governance, which was ironically awarded Best Corporate governance company. God knows who did that!!

Ya Rite!
Posted by NZ, Dubai, UAE on Sunday 18 January 2009 at 15:15 UAE time


Its still nothing compared to the Mayhem caused due to oversight of US regulators ...Lehman, Citigroup, FM..the list is endless. India is a self- reliant economy, with a strong domestic market..the stock market has fallen as FII, presumably from US have pulled out their funds to meet redemptions of jittery investors back home. In short, INDIA IS STILL BETTER PLACED (in terms of prospects) THAN ANY OTHER ECONOMY. Satyam is nothing but an ABBERATION, Indian banks are still going strong based on real money unlike western banks that were stashed junk bonds in their balance sheets.

Click here to post a comment

Add your Comment All posts are sent to the administrator for review and are published only after approval. ArabianBusiness.com reserves the right to remove any comment at any time for any reason. Please keep your responses appropriate and on topic. Arabian Business would like to point out that only comments relevant to the story will be published. Any containing personal insults or inappropriate language will not be approved.
Name *
Remember me on this computer
Email *	(Your email address will not be published)
City
Country
Subject *
Comment *
Notify me of further comments
Enter the words above *
Please click post only once - your comment will not be published immediately.

MORE FROM ARABIANBUSINESS.COM