Dubai warned to avoid US-style consumer society
by This email address is being protected from spam bots, you need Javascript enabled to view it on Sunday, 31 May 2009
Dubai is close to adopting an aggressive US-style consumer society which could be "destructive and dangerous to its people", a world famous sociologist has claimed.
In comments made during a talk hosted by the Dubai School of Government, George Ritzer, an American professor at the University of Maryland, said the economic crisis was likely to wipe out many of the "cathedrals of consumption" such as giant shopping malls, cruise ships, and theme parks.
“While the US has emerged as the primary example of a hyper-consumer society, with credit cards given even to college kids without jobs, other societies such as Macau or Dubai are following this pattern, which may prove extremely dangerous and destructive to its people,” Ritzer said.
Dubai is a mecca for shopping malls and theme parks. Dubailand is a $64bn leisure and entertainment theme park currently under construction in the emirate.
Anecdotal evidence has suggested that Dubai retail sales are around 20 percent down on last year.
Ritzer said globalisation in the West - particularly in the US - over the last 50 years had been marked by a push "for the tallest building, the biggest burger, the largest meal - anything that would wow consumers and make then consumer even more".
“Once people stop coming to these ‘cathedrals of consumption,’ the spectacle or ‘wow factor’ is greatly reduced. Then there is even less reason to come,” he added.
“We are witnessing a change in perception and the reality is hitting people hard. When people are heading in a particular way with a lot of energy, the only way they will stop is when they hit a wall. I think the recession that we are witnessing currently is a wall.”
Ritzer is author of a number of books including the ‘The McDonaldization of Society’ and ‘Enchanting a Disenchanted World’. He holds an honourary doctorate from La Trobe University, Melbourne, Australia.
READERS' COMMENTS
Posted by Sand Jockey, Dubai on Monday 8 June 2009 at 14:58 UAE time
Since when did the US become the only consumer nation in the world? Or the only fat one for that matter?
Consumerism isn't a factor of a society, it is a factor of the individuals within that society. Take control of your own life and quit blaming others for your ills. If you couldn't pay for that large screen TV then you shouldn't have bought it. If you really couldn't afford that villa in AR then you shouldn't have bought it. If you didn't need those puffy lips then you shouldn't have bought them....yep, all those excesses are tied to an individuals desire to "keep up with the Jones'".
I have credit cards and try to keep them at a zero, or close to zero, balance at all times.
I have debt, but I also have savings
I have not always had everything I wanted (and still don't) but I have a very good life.
It isn't the UAE, or the US, or any other country, that makes people spend. It is the people who spend 'cause they want to.
@Simone - Word of advice. Cut up the credit card NOW. Don't wait for it to be paid off.
SJ
Posted by Steve, Dubai, UAE on Monday 8 June 2009 at 11:13 UAE time
I got here a year ago and was amazed at the absolute matrerialistic and self absorbed live in Dubai. People where walking around like mindless zombies dispensing cash (or mostly credit) for the worst quality service on the planet.
Store owners got so caught up in this madness that they treated paying customers like a nuisance to be served as quickly and badly as possible, just to get to the next idiot. I think Dubai is now a much nicer place to live in. This crisis purged the city of most of these irrational spenders and retailers and this summer will hopefully finish the job.
Dubai will be the better for it.
Posted by Dude, Dubai, United Arab Emirates on Monday 1 June 2009 at 05:28 UAE time
I have submitted a comment on the credit card article that warned about people leaving the country without paying their debts and Mr. ArabianBusiness.Com censorship rejected it because it has very valuable advises from my practical and professional experience.
Today Dubai is already hold a lot of similarities to the US market because there have been lack of planning (in terms of development projects focused on retail and residential freehold) and lack of regulations to prevent banks from committing a suicide against themselves, customers, and economy through uncontrolled leveraging they have allowed for individuals and projects that have no theoretical ability to payback which they have even make difficult by compounding interest at crazy rates which outpace any return on the Dirham.
Posted by Arsal, Dubai, UAE on Sunday 31 May 2009 at 22:24 UAE time
Great article and what a couch potato of a city we live in, sort of reminds me of a scene from Wall-E on consumerism and capitalism!
Click here to post a comment
MORE FROM ARABIANBUSINESS.COM
TOP IN MIDDLE EAST POLITICS & ECONOMICS
TOP MIDDLE EAST BUSINESS STORIES
ALSO IN MIDDLE EAST POLITICS & ECONOMICS
LATEST MIDDLE EAST BUSINESS NEWS
- Sport: Lee Westwood wins Race to Dubai
- Construction & Industry: Qatar signs $22.79bn rail deal with Deutsche Bahn
- Media & Marketing: Dubai developers see negative press reports decline
- Transportation: Kuwait to allocate Iran port to boost trade
- Retail: Sunseeker ME announces regional expansion plans




