Dubai Holding-Emaar merger deal raises questions

MERGER QUESTIONS: Analysts raise concerns over land values of the three real estate units of Dubai Holding that are due to merge with Emaar Properties. (Getty Images)

Analysts on Monday raised doubts over the value of the land owned by the three units of Dubai Holding that developer Emaar is to merge with.

On Sunday Emaar said the entity resulting from a proposed merger with three units of Dubai Holding, which include developers Sama Dubai, Dubai Properties and Tatweer, will have combined assets worth AED194bn ($52.85bn).

There is speculation as to what these assets will consist of. Analysts said they could include a significant land bank, although questions have been raised about how valuable this would be in the wake of the real estate collapse in Dubai.

Robert McKinnon, managing director of equity research at Dubai-based investment bank Al Mal Capital said: ''There are a lot of questions marks in terms of the valuation.''

''The market couldn’t care less about the value recognised on their balance sheet because what is the land really worth in market terms? If they [developers merging with Emaar] wanted to monetise their land bank, what price would they get? That is what the market cares about,'' he added.

According to official figures from the Dubai Land Department a 17170 sq ft plot of land was sold in Nad Al Hamar for AED3.09m on Monday. A 15718 sq ft plot in the Ranches was acquired for AED2.67m on the same day.

Another analyst questioned the viability of Emaar adding more land in Dubai to its portfolio.

''Land bank valuation can exhibit high volatility in stress markets and therefore true value of land as an asset is tough to gauge. What needs to be assessed is the actual economic value to Emaar from holding additional land in Dubai,'' said Saud Masud, an analyst at Swiss investment bank UBS.

''Will property be built upon it in the near term, what is the potential sale value per square foot and to whom may the land be sold to? How marketable is the land?'' he added.

In a letter posted on Emaar’s website on Sunday the company’s chairman Mohamed Alabbar said: ''Based on preliminary review, Dubai Properties, Sama and Tatweer have a robust and strategic asset base (attractive land bank) which will contribute positively to consolidation.''

Standard & Poor's meanwhile on Monday revised the CreditWatch implications for its 'BBB+' long-term credit ratings on Emaar to developing from negative.

The agency said the rating action reflected the prospective benefits on Emaar Properties’ credit profile from the merger.

But the developing implications also reflect the downward pressure on the ratings from the weak Dubai real estate markets if the merger is not completed, it added.

"The current ratings on Emaar reflect the group's important role and strong position in the Dubai property development market as one of three government-related master developers, and its strong relationship with, and minority ownership by, the government of Dubai," said S&P credit analyst Alf Stenqvist.

Emaar shares fell two percent in trading on Monday, closing at AED2.83.

Print | Email | Discuss this article

| Share |

READERS' COMMENTS

Merger Deal Concerns
Posted by Jack, London, England on Tuesday 30 June 2009 at 10:50 UAE time


This follows the sentiment expressed in my comment sent in response (unpublished) to the original article. The Dubai Holding developers have massive debts to restructure and 'settle' before Emaar can even think about the 'real' value of the merged conglomerate and this is being reflected by the cautious if negative market interest.

As for the 'attractive landbank', I hear that there are considerable issues with development sites outside the UAE, delayed stage investment and contract signing is questioning contractual ownership along with the suitability of the sites for construction without excessive ground preparation.

Emaar consolidation
Posted by venkat on Tuesday 30 June 2009 at 08:54 UAE time


Emaar consolidation with Dubai holding will be good if transperancy of the valuation ,Debts is done. what is the short term and long term business plan and how does the same will affect the stake holders. I always felt Emaar a robust organisation with lot of vision and in the short term nothing is really happening in its favour. Hope Emaar consilidates as it has always been the market leader in real estate.

interesting indeed
Posted by The Councillor, Abu Dhabi, UAE on Tuesday 30 June 2009 at 01:58 UAE time

the other important issue is the level of debt these entities have and if they will be transferred to to Emaar's accounts...

Click here to post a comment

Add your Comment All posts are sent to the administrator for review and are published only after approval. ArabianBusiness.com reserves the right to remove any comment at any time for any reason. Please keep your responses appropriate and on topic.
Name *
Remember me on this computer
Email *	(Your email address will not be published)
City
Country
Subject *
Comment *
Notify me of further comments
Enter the words above *
Please click post only once - your comment will not be published immediately.

MORE FROM ARABIANBUSINESS.COM