Arabtec CEO hits back over BBC's labour camp claims

EXCLUSIVE: Company chief says TV show on plight of construction workers was 'unfair'.

Arabtec Holding chief executive Riad Kamal on Wednesday hit back at a documentary by the BBC’s Panorama show which claimed the firm’s labour camps were filthy and overcrowded.

In a strong response to the findings of the programme, Kamal accused Panorama of being unfair in its reporting of the living and working conditions of workers of Arabtec Construction, a subsidiary of Arabtec Holding.

Arabtec, one of the largest contractors in the UAE which employs a total of 62,000 people, had more than 20 camps in Dubai and Abu Dhabi which were cleaned daily, Kamal told Arabian Business in an exclusive interview.

He said the company also employed a hygiene specialist who headed a team that trained workers about the importance of basic hygiene and nutrition.

Cameras for the current affairs TV programme, which aired in the UK this week, filmed overflowing raw sewage leaking through one Arabtec camp.

One worker complained the toilets were so filthy they were unusable and about garbage and water blocking the roads around the camp.

“They have been very unfair not only to Arabtec but to Dubai,” said Kamal, who said he had not seen the programme but had read a BBC press release about the documentary’s findings.

“Our camps are cleaned every day and our septic tanks are pumped out continuously. We have an enormous number of tankers working 24 hours emptying sewage from our tanks.

“I am not sure when and where they (Panorama) went into any of our camps. It may be that during the rainy season some of the tanks overflowed, but this is not the norm.”

He said supervisors ensured toilets in the camps were cleaned every day but the company had no control over when they were used.

Kamal said many of the workers came from poor backgrounds and their standard of cleanliness was not as high as the firm would like.

He firmly rejected allegations of overcrowding in rooms in the camps, claiming a maximum of six workers lived in each room.

All rooms were well ventilated and rooms where the men slept were air-conditioned and had sufficient windows, he said.

The camps provided “excellent” cooking facilities for the workers, with a medical team of nurses and a doctor looking after their medical needs. If workers were found to be unfit they were referred to a medical clinic, he said.

All labourers were covered by an insurance scheme, he added.

“We are providing facilities for the men compatible with their expectations and directions we have been given by Dubai Municipality,” he said.

He said a claim by the programme that workers were earning between $120 and $140 per month for ten to 12 hours work a day was untrue.

He said the BBC had not checked with Arabtec wage levels of workers.

He said the basic monthly wage of an unskilled labourer based on an eight-hour day (six days a week) started at $177, with skilled workers' wages starting at $225.

Depending on the amount of overtime done by workers, the average take-home wage for an unskilled labourer was $225 a month, with a skilled labourer taking home about $277 a month, he said. Overtime work, which averages two hours a day, was paid at 25 percent higher than the basic wage, in accordance with industry standards.

“I would have expected a respectable media party to come and sit with us and clear the figures before publishing wrong figures.

“We are the largest construction company in the UAE and these wages are a measure of what construction labour across the industry is getting paid,” he said.

All the major contractors in the UAE, together with the Contractors’ Association, and the Ministry of Labour had agreed a couple of years ago what wage increases should be given to workers, he said.

Arabtec had no control over how much workers paid to recruitment companies in their home countries to come and work in the UAE, but issued instructions to recruiters not to exceed their costs plus a minimum charge, he said.

“A lot of the workers have paid over the top to their recruitment firms to come here,” Kamal admitted.

But he said workers would be able to repay the costs incurred within two to three months of work in the UAE.

He said Arabtec kept labourers’ passports for “security” reasons but that they were able to regain their passport and leave the UAE whenever they chose.

He said some Arabtec workers had been working for the firm for 10-15 years.

Meanwhile, the UAE's Ministry of Labour has said it will investigatethe documentary's claims.

Related:
Join the Discussion

Disclaimer:The view expressed here by our readers are not necessarily shared by Arabian Business, its employees, sponsors or its advertisers.

NOTE: Comments posted on arabianbusiness.com may be printed in the magazine Arabian Business

Please post responsibly. Commenter Rules

Posted by: Abdul Rasheed

what he said 40% is true....

Posted by: RK

Rainy season, can someone enlighten me, when is the rainy season in Dubai which the CEO of ARABTEC (see the article above.) is refering to.

Posted by: hamdan mohamed(hamdan@imail.ae)

Dear HZ and readers, i wont write more than what you wrote Mr HZ, as you took the words out of my mouth as they said. why they did not cover the other 20 labor camps ? BBC should go to the home country of these labors to see how they live there for 2 to 4 USD per month with hard all day work. they live in heaven in here with every thing starting form the place they live at to the 3 meals they get to the health. reader should not compare the salary of in UAE or other countries to say these people does not get paid well. no one force them to come to UAE to work. in Europe you can see many immigrant who do low jobs as you call it for so much less than Europeans !! why dont BBC talk about that ? they get used and many times dont get paid, simply because they cant complain to the authorities. i would like the BBC to do a report about other camps but not with the thief ways that they have done. again the way they did just show how low they could go to try killing an ICON image such as Dubai.

Posted by: Mark

Having read most different viewpoints and having visited Dubai on numerous ocassions, I have the following point to make. 1) Exagerrated or not, these conditions are apalling and for those who say well nobody forced them! Why not consider the same situation existing in the UK. Would you be proud if your entire economy was made up of a leisure class (15% native) who's growth and luxury are at the expense of a basic roof, latrine and some basic human respect. And no! im not anti capatalist but this is the 21st century and whilst we need to clean up the planet. We must also clean up our act and stop supporting these abuses.

Posted by: Investor

Would be nice to see some of the senior executives of Arabtec, and other companies spend a few nights in the camps - "those with excellent facilities". In the west, that's what judges have asked some slumlords to do.... go spend a few nights in their own apartments. No matter how biased the BBC etc. may be, they've done more with a few programs than 20 years of embassy & labor ministry interventions.

All comments are subject to approval before appearing

Further reading

Features & Analysis
Railways are huge priority for the GCC

Railways are huge priority for the GCC

Rail has the potential to dramatically affect Gulf economies...

Cash crunch at Saudi firm casts shadow over Lebanon's Hariris

Cash crunch at Saudi firm casts shadow over Lebanon's Hariris

The troubles at Saudi Oger have led to a cash crunch and layoffs...

Abandoned in Saudi desert camps, migrant workers won't leave without pay

Abandoned in Saudi desert camps, migrant workers won't leave without pay

Plight of workers has alarmed their home countries and drawn...

4
Most Discussed
sponsoredTracking