Brazil's fury over Saudi beef imports ban

Latin American country threatens to complain to World Trade Org over mad cow disease

The world's top beef exporter, Brazil, will give countries that curbed imports of its beef after a case of mad cow disease until March to drop the measures or it will file a complaint at the World Trade Organisation, farm ministry officials have said.

Five countries including Saudi Arabia and Egypt, have implemented full or partial bans on Brazilian beef imports since confirmation this month of a case of atypical bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE), or mad cow disease, in a cow that died in 2010.

Atypical BSE cases can occur spontaneously in elderly cattle and the 13-year-old animal in the Brazilian case never developed full-blown BSE, testing instead positive for a protein that is the causal agent of mad cow disease.

Brazil had previously launched a diplomatic offensive to fend off restrictions over the death of the cow in the southern state of Parana which was confirmed only this month by Brazilian authorities.

But now Brazil has promised to take retaliatory action against countries rejecting its beef, saying there are no grounds for such action.

"March is the deadline," said Enio Marques Pereira, Secretary for Animal and Plant Health at Brazil's farm ministry, after a meeting at the World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE) headquarters on Friday.

Officials stressed Brazil has kept its status as a country presenting negligible BSE risk under an OIE classification, and that OIE norms consider safe for consumption products like red meat and gelatine, even when BSE has been declared in a country.

The Brazilian cow in question never entered the food chain.

Countries restricting Brazilian beef include Egypt and Saudi Arabia which rank among Brazil's top 10 beef buyers, but Marques said the economic impact so far was "very low", noting that Egypt was only banning meat from the region where the BSE case occurred. Saudi Arabia has suspended Brazilian beef outright.

The other countries which have imposed temporary bans are South Africa, Japan and China.

The OIE welcomed the fact that Brazil had managed to detect the atypical case in a national herd of more than 200 million, though logistical problems at a laboratory delayed the analysis of the animal's tissue since its death in 2010.

"We're rather reassured by the fact that Brazil reported this case," Bernard Vallat, director general of the OIE, said.

He stressed that an end to the use of cattle feed containing matter from ruminant animals had succeeded in nearly eradicating BSE after tens of thousands of cases in the 1980s and 1990s, mostly in Britain.

Join the Discussion

Disclaimer:The view expressed here by our readers are not necessarily shared by Arabian Business, its employees, sponsors or its advertisers.

NOTE: Comments posted on may be printed in the magazine Arabian Business

Please post responsibly. Commenter Rules

Posted by: Abdul hafeez Sheikh

Brazil must follows the rules and regulations KSA while making any batch of beef or other edible items to KSA . The beef should be halal and the feed which is given to the cows should not contain any elements or constituents which are in any way objectionable to Muslims . I hope Brazile understands the situation and shall satisfy Saudi authorities by the actions they need to take for KSA govt sanctification . It should be noted that the KSA Government looks after the interests of all Muslims of the world , as they go to Saudia for pilgrimage and take food.

Posted by: Bob

Why should any country be forced to by another's product. If Saudi do not want Brazilian beef then that's there prerogative. If they publicly claim the beef is defective in some way and its not then fine Brazil can take legal action for this. However Saudi or any other country should be allowed to ban imports into their own country as and when they want.

Posted by: z

Maybe its time for other markets to Ban Saudi Oil and other exports so that it teaches the saudi authorities how to be as arrogant as they are. Its amazing that the Americans could not do anything over the USA beef ban that has been in effect in over 1 year... What we all would do in the Name of Oil....

Posted by: Emirateshillbaba

Mr. Z u better be ready to bend over backwards for OIL, and if you don't understand economics, especially economics related to OIL its better rather then sounding silly. You ban Saudi oil, the price of oil will go to a 1000 dollars per barrel and no other country has the reserve capacity to fill the gap. The is no comparison between beef and oil, i can live without beef but i certainly cannot live without OIL.

All comments are subject to approval before appearing

More from Arabian Business

Bahrain firm aims to revolutionise car ownership in the UK

KSA is elected to the UN Women’s Rights Commission. Yes, you read that correctly

Etihad takes delivery of final A380 plane from Airbus

Dubai consumer comparison website wins extra $3.5m funding

Arabtec rights-issue investors left with 33% loss in one week

Brand View: Investing for the future