Canada blocks network sale to Egypt's Sawiris over "security concerns"

  • Share via facebook
  • Tweet this
  • Bookmark and Share
Sawiris said in the statement that Accelero Capital Holdings is disappointed by the Government of Canada's unfounded and unexpected decision.

Sawiris said in the statement that Accelero Capital Holdings is disappointed by the Government of Canada's unfounded and unexpected decision.

The Canadian government said on Monday it blocked a bid from a company controlled by Egyptian telecom tycoon Naguib Sawiris to buy a fiber optic network, citing national security concerns.

The surprise move by the country's Conservative government was made with little explanation and comes as many question its appetite for foreign investment in sectors ranging from telecommunications to oil sands.

Manitoba Telecom Services Inc (MTS) had announced in May it would sell its Allstream fibre optic network for C$520m ($503.4m) to Accelero Capital Holdings, which is controlled by the Egyptian telecom magnate.

But MTS said late on Monday the federal government blocked the deal, citing "unspecified national security concerns."

The government also rejected MTS and Accelero's offer to take necessary actions to address those concerns, the company said in a statement on Monday.

Canadian Industry Minister James Moore confirmed in a brief statement that the deal was blocked under the national security provisions of the Investment Canada Act.

The statement did not provide any specific details on the government's concerns, but it noted that MTS Allstream operates a national fibre optic network that provides critical telecom services to businesses and governments, including the Canadian government.

The government declined to comment further.

Canada has rarely used its veto power to block a foreign acquisition of a Canadian asset under the Investment Canada Act.

The legislation gives the government wide-ranging powers to review whether such deals are of "net benefit" to the country and whether they pose a threat to national security.

In 2010 it blocked mining giant BHP Billiton's $39bn bid for the world's top fertiliser company Potash Corp , stating that the deal was not of "net benefit" to Canada.

This followed a 2008 decision to block MacDonald Dettwiler's attempt to sell its satellite division to Alliant Techsystems Inc, due to national security concerns.

The rejection of the Allstream deal comes as struggling smartphone maker BlackBerry, one of Canada's best- known technology companies, is in talks with foreign players including Cisco Systems, Google Inc and SAP about selling them all or parts of itself, sources have told Reuters.

Accelero said in a statement it was "very disappointed" by the Canadian government's unexpected rejection of its proposed acquisition of Allstream.

"Throughout this process, we were comforted by Industry Canada that our filings were in order, our submissions complete and constructive, and our proposed binding undertakings serious and substantive so that the transaction would meet the 'net benefit' test," Sawiris said in the statement.

"We are disappointed by the Government of Canada's unfounded and unexpected decision."

The decision also raises questions about the government's stated goal of attracting foreign investment to boost competition in the telecom sector.

The government was locked in a war of words with Canada's top telecom players - Rogers Communications, BCE Inc and Telus Corp - over most of the summer.

The three Canadian telecom giants accused the government of skewing rules for its wireless spectrum auction that began last month in favor of foreign players.

The government countered that its rules were designed to boost competition in the sector and reduce prices for Canadian consumers.

The issue became a moot point last month, after no major foreign telecom player registered to participate in the auction process.

Accelero said it believes its investment in Allstream would have contributed to increased competition in Canada's telecom sector and sent a strong message that Canada's telecom sector is open to foreign investment.

Sawiris has been closely involved in the Canadian telecom sector for a few years now and he was instrumental in initially bankrolling wireless start-up Wind Mobile.

Join the Discussion

Disclaimer:The view expressed here by our readers are not necessarily shared by Arabian Business, its employees, sponsors or its advertisers.

Please post responsibly. Commenter Rules

Posted by: procan

This old news guys , he talked about his money but would not put it on the line. He was all talk

Posted by: David

Not very professional or constructive by the Canadians. If they did not want these investors they should have disqualified them earlier in the process. this not only hurt the foreign investment to Canada, it also hurts the Canadian companies and question their ability to grow, merge, sell or enhance themselves.

This current Canadian government is less transparent than predecessors. Time for you Canadians to be smarter in selecting your leadership.

I doubt Canada could have dared to mess with a an investor form my country, decision makers would be eaten alive by my community if they dare to even suggest national security as an excuse.

Sorry for Sawiris, he is a great investor and made an impact where ever he invested. Tough luck buddy!

Posted by: Telcoguy

@Vicky, please this is another baseless protectionist move just to please the crowds. Same as the US blocking the Dubai port deal some years ago. Foreign ownership does not mean that the operation will not be under scrutiny of the local authorities and regulators

Or all the issues involving Huawei, specially after all we have seen going on with US companies. Ain't amazing how sensitive some people are towards citizens' privacy?

If we really had any concern about national security we would not have all our chips made in a few factories in China and most of our computer and other equipment too

Posted by: Vicky

It is a good decision to bar companies from specific backdrop/ regions on national security grounds. Glad that Canada recognizes the need to identify and act on the trend to acquire critical technology and financial sectors in established markets. One can never be totally sure of investors' motives but better be safe than sorry. Canada has never been a risk-taking and investor obsessed country. It is hard to expect a change all of a sudden, especially with security issues being so real in modern times.

Posted by: think twice

more investors are flocking to canada then anywhere else, you speak of dubai's real estate market come see canada's in particular toronto's. and what are you comparing transparency too? dubai? other gulf or arab countries? fyi sawiris is already an investor with mobilicity a wireless company based in the toronto area which is failing maybe that's why they refused it so that they don't fail mts.

Posted by: procan

We do not deal with countries at war.

Enter the words above: Enter the numbers you hear:

All comments are subject to approval before appearing

Further reading

Features & Analysis
UAE's role in the new space race

UAE's role in the new space race

In the last five years, the UAE has invested heavily in a bid...

An Instagram photo is worth a thousand words

An Instagram photo is worth a thousand words

Instagram has become the social media platform of choice for...

Fear and roaming in the Gulf

Fear and roaming in the Gulf

The Gulf’s telecommunications giants are once more pushing ahead...

Most Discussed
  • 54
    Three UAE women attacked with hammer at London hotel

    I really feel that Arabian Business.Com should now close this comments page. This should be all about sympathy for the families not what it is/has turned... more

    Wednesday, 16 April 2014 1:06 PM - Adrienne
  • 51
    Why Dubai isn't a plastic city

    What is definitely not a plastic city. The Arabs have a culture dating back to several centuries. 50 years back Dubai was just a fishing village. Today... more

    Tuesday, 8 April 2014 3:49 PM - P. MADHUSUDAN
  • 48
    DMCC boss Ahmed Bin Sulayem entertains Robert Mugabe in Dubai

    @fga ''However today, simply because he decided to dispossess a few white farmers of their land and redistribute to the poorer indigenous blacks'' more

    Sunday, 13 April 2014 3:02 PM - Matt Williams