Economic pressures behind Kuwait's expat clampdown

  • Share via facebook
  • Tweet this
  • Bookmark and Share
(Photo for illustrative purposes only)

(Photo for illustrative purposes only)

The narrow, cracked streets of the district of Jleeb al-Shuyoukh, down the road from Kuwait's main airport, would normally be bustling with Indian and Bangladeshi workers by late morning, just before the summer sun becomes unbearable.

But since Kuwaiti police launched a series of raids about two months ago, saying they were tracking down illegal labourers, the streets are almost empty and many small businesses have closed their doors, residents say.

In the last few months, authorities have deported thousands of mainly low-paid Asian workers from the Gulf Arab state for working without the correct visa or residency papers or for repeat traffic offences, according to local media and residents. A government minister has called for a reduction in the number of "excess" foreign workers in Kuwait.

The oil-rich country relies heavily on foreign workers to perform low-paying and strenuous jobs in sectors such as construction and services; foreigners make up about 69 percent of Kuwait's 3.8 million population.

Pressure to limit their numbers has been growing among some Kuwaitis who argue that too many workers are a burden on the state. They say that instead of bringing in foreigners, Kuwait should be trying harder to cut unemployment among its own nationals, which analysts estimate above 3.0 percent.

If this pressure continues to grow, it could have a major effect on Kuwait's economy, limiting its access to low-cost labour, while reducing flows of money to countries which supply foreign workers such as India, Bangladesh, Pakistan and the Philippines.

"Kuwait is keen to regulate the labour market because of the imbalance in the demographics," Social Affairs and Labour Minister Thikra al-Rashidi told Reuters, saying the number of foreigners in Kuwait had increased 12.4 percent between 2008 and 2012.

"We have respect for all the expatriates who have participated in the labour market and contributed to the development of Kuwait," she said, but added that there was an excess of unskilled "marginal" workers who were not contributing to the economy in a positive way.

Kuwait's effort to limit expatriate workers is mirrored in several other Gulf countries, which want to curb large foreign populations to address demands for jobs among their own citizens.

Saudi Arabia has deported tens of thousands of illegal foreign workers this year; in February, Oman's government said it would impose a cap on the number of foreigners.

Rashidi has called for the flow of foreigners coming to Kuwait to be reduced by 100,000 every year for the next decade, mainly by cutting down on unskilled workers entering the country and targeting people who are working illegally.

Her ministry's proposal is still in the planning stages but it has coincided with separate steps taken by other government bodies towards foreigners.

Kuwait has deported around 3,000 Indians since the latest campaign started, the Arab Times reported this week, quoting the Indian ambassador. The Indian embassy told Reuters the figure was "approximate". Other nationalities have also been affected.

"The police caught so many people. They came at any time, morning, afternoon, night," said Rashed, a 36-year-old Bangladeshi barber in Jleeb.

Before the raids, he usually had around 20 customers by late morning, but that morning there had been none, he said, declining to give his full name for fear of getting in trouble with authorities. He said he had not experienced such a strict police crackdown since he came to Kuwait 11 years ago.

Contacted by Reuters, the Interior Ministry did not give figures for the number of people deported for traffic offences or incorrect paperwork, but it said laws were applied fairly.

"It is the right of any state...to take appropriate legal action to ensure stability and security of the country," it said in a statement. It added, "The Interior Ministry denies the charge that it is targeting expatriates."

Diplomats from the Indian and Bangladeshi embassies have appealed for an amnesty period before workers are deported, similar to one granted by Saudi Arabia.

"We conveyed our concern that our legal people should not be deported, and the deported people should take their salaries and dues from their sponsors," said Ali Reza, First Secretary at the Embassy of Bangladesh in Kuwait.

Hundreds of Indians held a rare public gathering outside their embassy last week to demand information about people who had been detained or deported.

Critics of the policy say steep cuts in the foreign workforce are not economically feasible, especially since more labourers will be needed to implement a KD30bn ($108bn) development plan which includes building a new airport terminal, an oil refinery and hospitals.

Some companies prefer to employ foreigners rather than Kuwaitis who, they say, often seek higher pay and cannot be as easily dismissed under labour laws.

But the backlash against foreign workers is not purely economic; they have been blamed in some local media for aggravating social problems.

"Kuwait's interest calls for washing our hands of the excessive number of expatriates," an article in the al-Watan newspaper said in April. "Cutting the number of immigrants could help any country as it helps reduce traffic congestion, high consumption of water and electricity, crimes and violations of law."

In another controversial move, the government is studying a proposal to reserve morning hours for Kuwaitis only at public health clinics. The plan would not affect the private hospitals frequented by wealthier expatriates.

After Kuwait's main civil rights group said the plan was discriminatory, the Ministry of Health said in a statement: "The proposal is intended to ease the overcrowding at clinics that continues to increase for regular check-ups." It stressed the new policy would not include emergency care.

Shamlan Alissa, an associate professor at Kuwait University, said it was not right that foreigners could be deported for repeat traffic violations, while the worst that a Kuwaiti might face would be suspension of his driving licence, an impounded car or a fine.

His comments, printed in al-Watan, provoked a public reaction which was "not that pleasant", he said. "There is a popular hatred towards foreigners because we (Kuwaitis) are only 30 percent" of the population."

Ghanem al-Najjar, a professor of political science at Kuwait University who has campaigned for migrant workers in the past, said the government should target businessmen and agencies who brought in thousands of labourers for projects and then dismissed some of them, forcing them to look for work elsewhere.

"There are people bringing them in, the residency traders - these are the people who are not touched. That is a major cause of the problem," he said.

Abdullah, a 35-year-old taxi driver from Pakistan, said he had stopped driving his car into Jleeb because he feared getting stopped, even though he always carried the correct papers.

Some labour agencies in Kuwait have duped foreigners by charging them hundreds of dollars for processing a work permit and then not giving them a position, forcing them to turn to illegal jobs, he said.

Foreigners helped to rebuild Kuwait after the 1990 Iraqi invasion but now feel unwelcome even if they are there legally, he added. "They just used us and now they want to throw us away."

Related:
Join the Discussion

Disclaimer:The view expressed here by our readers are not necessarily shared by Arabian Business, its employees, sponsors or its advertisers.

Please post responsibly. Commenter Rules

Posted by: Geoff W

I can't wait to see how all of these measures materialize. Kuwaitis have to realize that expats only fill those jobs where locals are unable to perform the job - and these jobs are thousands. Where would you find capable Kuwaiti doctors, engineers and technicians? Why would any Kuwaiti even go for higher studies when he can just lay back and take Government stipends and borrow loans which he will never pay back?

Posted by: Ace


It is Ok to accept the argument that the current measure are meant to reduce unregulated labor market.

But it seems to overlook the fact that growth of any economy the presence of a unregulated labor force who can be directed to different sites and undertake non permanent nature of jobs is highly essential.

Posted by: Saudi

It?s a matter of logic. An illegal immigrant will rarely if ever make the money needed to support themselves. Their options are just more limited. At some point they just start to degrade society. Expats will enjoy the fruits of the gulf's wealth, and still hate our guts behind our backs.

Posted by: mumeen

PPM and Oldtimer are so right -

Posted by: PPM


To be honest most expats from Asia accept discrimination because they suffer from so much colour, caste, creed based bigotry in their home countries anyway.
When they start to hate your guts is when they stop getting paid and have no way to change employer nor to - efficiently - take their employer to court and guarantee to get their dues.
Most Gulf states have no shortage of people employed to check on employee sponsorship or visa status but appear to neither have nor want to have anybody to check on employers' compliance with contracts and the actual law of the land.

Posted by: Oldtimer

Illegal workers (NOT Immigrants) should be found and deported beacause they have violated the residency laws of the country. NOBODY disputes that. But when expats with legal residency are unfairly targeted and harassed, that is deplorable. Either limit the intake of foreigners to what the market forces require and have a strictly enforced law that keeps it that way. But after an expat applies for a job, passes the interview or other criteria and joins work, RESPECT that individual because he is contributing positively to your economy. He has filled a vacancy that your national could/would not! Expats DO NOT hate your guts but is grateful for the opportunity to earn decent wages to sustain his family. What he does hate is unfair DISCRIMINATION despite being a law-abiding legal resident.


Posted by: RAH

I think, I think, I think.. This crackdown has happened in response to the run up to the Constitutional Court's ruling this Sunday on the Amir's past decree of one vote per person which has angered the opposition and made them go out into the streets.

I think the reason of this crackdown is to scare the expats into hiding so that IF the court ruled the Amir acted constitutionally by changing the voting system (i.e. his right as Amir), the opposition have vowed to cause chaos and won't accept this ruling. This means that the police will have one helluva time in getting law and order back.

As a result, with expats making up 70% of Kuwait, scare them into hiding, leaves just 30% of the population (i.e. the Kuwaitis) out to cause chaos. Now remove the infants and elderly, that'll be 20% who may cause chaos. Remove those uninterested in chaos, leaves you with 10% which means the police can better handle the situation!

That's what I think.

Posted by: marvin

Why do you think that expats care about your political system? They don't and this disputes your arrogant theory. They only want to make a living and get out of your country with no care for the country, because of how they were treated by the system.

Posted by: marvin

The subcontinent needs to prepare for all their nationals that will be returning home in an exedus from the Gulf. Why should the Gulf welcome illegal nationals, either they validate their stay according to the law in these nations or they return to their homeland.

Posted by: Kuwaiti

Well said. There were enough opportunities (Amnesty) for the illegal to go back home. Many of them never went back may be fearing arrest for crime committed back home.

Enter the words above: Enter the numbers you hear:

All comments are subject to approval before appearing

Further reading

Features & Analysis
Q&A with Dubai Chamber

Q&A with Dubai Chamber

We spoke with Essa Al Zaabi of Dubai Chamber of Commerce to find...

The politics of big data

The politics of big data

The UAE may be one of the fastest adopters of e-government initiatives...

Iraqi Islamists' gains pose challenge to al Qaeda leader

Iraqi Islamists' gains pose challenge to al Qaeda leader

ISIL has captured swathes of territory in northwest and central...

1
Most Discussed