Where did it all go wrong for Arabtec?

The departure of CEO Hasan Ismaik leaves more questions than answers for the contractor’s shareholders.

The fact that Arabtec’s share price immediately started trending back upwards after investors heard that chief executive Hasan Abdullah Ismaik was leaving the company said it all. We didn’t know a great deal about him before he took on the top job, and we still don’t know a great deal about him now.

After spending a year in charge of the UAE’s most important construction firm, Ismaik’s tenure was characterised by plenty of bombast and plenty of grandiose announcements.

There were also a couple of awkward moments, such as a television interview where Ismaik claimed that the company was looking for a merger with two major Gulf construction firms, only for a press statement to be released a day later denying that any talks had taken place. 

There’s no doubt that Arabtec’s backlog has grown substantially, but it remains unclear how the company will be able to take on the massive amount of work it has won. There also doesn’t seem to be any movement on two joint ventures the company signed last year with Samsung Engineering (to bid for energy, utility and infrastructure work) and GS Engineering and Construction Corp (for rail, bridges, ports and tunnels).

Not that any of this will bother Ismaik now. The last 12 months have made him an extremely rich man, mostly due to recent decisions to boost his stake in Arabtec to just over a quarter of the company. According to reports, he is already touting out that stake to “government entities”. 

But the last couple of weeks have been nothing short of a shambles. If there is ever a case study to determine the best way for a company to toss hundreds of millions of dirhams of shareholder value into the dustbin in the shortest time possible, then Arabtec’s recent performance would surely make it a contender. Over just six weeks, the firm’s stock has collapsed by as much as 50 percent at times, with the last nine days of trading — prompted by an extraordinary set of circumstances — proving especially damaging. 

Rumours that Arabtec was planning to delist, or that Aabar was divesting its stake in the company set the slide in motion, and despite an increasingly desperate series of statements on the Dubai bourse claiming that there was no rift between the contractor and its most important shareholder, investors weren’t convinced.

Making matters worse was a “temporary system glitch” (in the words of the Dubai Financial Market) last Sunday, which purported to show that Aabar had cut its stake in Arabtec from 18.85 percent to 14.32 percent. Given the huge focus on Arabtec — and particularly Arabtec’s ownership — the error did absolutely nothing to raise the profile of the bourse in the eyes of the international institutional investors the UAE has been struggling so hard to attract. 

With the stock still heading south, Ismaik announced last Wednesday — via the unusual medium of a newspaper interview, rather than a bourse statement — that he was quitting Arabtec.

But there are still plenty of questions unanswered. The source of funding for Ismaik’s stake purchase and a timeline of events leading to his departure may now never be established.

And why did Arabtec allow this saga to continue for so long, given that there was clearly a problem at boardroom level?

Of far more interest to shareholders right now would be a clear and concise statement, explaining how Arabtec plans to deliver on its ambitious plans, and clarifying the ownership situation.

The statement released last Thursday, which expressed “positive aspirations for a bright future and continuing to make more achievements, which aim to protect the rights of shareholders” doesn’t really cut it. Better communication, at the very least, must be a watchword in the future.

Join the Discussion

Disclaimer:The view expressed here by our readers are not necessarily shared by Arabian Business, its employees, sponsors or its advertisers.

NOTE: Comments posted on arabianbusiness.com may be printed in the magazine Arabian Business

Please post responsibly. Commenter Rules

Posted by: WHJ

To those under the illusion that market abuse is only a regional issue:
"There are few insights as to the full magnitude of market abuse in the EU. The LIBOR manipulation affected approximately ?7 trillion in loans and mortgages and ?250 trillion in derivatives. For equities, the European Commission estimates that market abuse disadvantaged investors by an amount equivalent to nearly 0.1% of market turnover (based on the 2013 market, this would total approximately ?8.5 billion).
The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) publishes statistics on ?market cleanliness? which capture abnormal price movements in the two days preceding the announcement of a takeover bid. The good news is that these movements, indicative of possible insider dealing, have gone down from 21.2% in 2010 to 14.9% in 2012, likely due to increasingly vigorous enforcement".

Posted by: Chris J

We all need to remember that insider trading is not illegal in this country, unlike most other countries. Second the company has a huge backlog. Given that a lot of business in the construction business in the Gulf is "bought", then the profit margins are probably questionable.
There is a clear need for proper stock exchange, as well as corporate governance in the UAE.

Posted by: WHJ

@Chris. Not quite;
"The Dubai and Abu-Dhabi Stock Exchange rules and regulations have their differences, but they are unanimous when it comes to insider trading actions. Insider trading is banned in two ways under the laws of Dubai and Abu-Dhabi. Authority Law thirty seven prohibits the exploitation of information that has not been made public that could possibly affect the prices of securities, stocks or bonds. Article thirty nine prohibits engaging in the trade of securities, stock or bonds based on knowledge obtained from non public information".

Posted by: Ron

I maybe saying the obvious but I think we need something here of the nature of the Securities Exchange Commission in the United States to launch an investigation into the Arabtec boardroom fiasco. I'm not an finance guru but this news is tremendously alarming and warrants an objective and detailed enquiry in all fairness to the people who hold equity here.

Posted by: Paul

Why is everybody surprised?
This is the way business is conducted in this region.
We should not forget where we are in spite of the fake illusion that this is a transparent ethical market.

Posted by: Muneer

This smacks of possible collusion and possible misuse of insider information. Should'nt the regulators (DFM?) investigate ?

Posted by: Simon

My very thoughts maneer...although the words you are most probably looking for are: 'Insider Trading'. A highly illegal state of affairs and regulated against all around the world...except, it seems, in the UAE.

A previous article by this very same author illuded to as much...

Where are the regulators hiding in all of this???

All comments are subject to approval before appearing

Further reading

Features & Analysis
Railways are huge priority for the GCC

Railways are huge priority for the GCC

Rail has the potential to dramatically affect Gulf economies...

Cash crunch at Saudi firm casts shadow over Lebanon's Hariris

Cash crunch at Saudi firm casts shadow over Lebanon's Hariris

The troubles at Saudi Oger have led to a cash crunch and layoffs...

Abandoned in Saudi desert camps, migrant workers won't leave without pay

Abandoned in Saudi desert camps, migrant workers won't leave without pay

Plight of workers has alarmed their home countries and drawn...

Most Discussed