We noticed you're blocking ads.

Keep supporting great journalism by turning off your ad blocker.

Questions about why you are seeing this? Contact us

Font Size

- Aa +

Mon 22 Jul 2013 05:21 PM

Font Size

- Aa +

Dubai boss says sacking rape case woman was wrong

Owner of The ONE says Wissam Al Mana’s decision to fire Norwegian was a mistake

Dubai boss says sacking rape case woman was wrong
Thomas Lundgren, the owner of Dubai-based The ONE.

The owner of Dubai-based The ONE has conceded it was “absolutely wrong” to sack a Norwegian woman who was charged with extramarital sex after reporting she had been raped.

Marte Deborah Dalelv was terminated from her job at Doha’s Al Mana Interiors, a franchise of The ONE, before being given a 16-month jail term. On Monday, Dubai’s Ruler Sheikh Mohammed pardoned her.

Speaking to Arabian Business, The ONE owner Thomas Lundgren said that, in hindsight, sacking Dalelv was “a mistake” and that Al Mana Interiors should have only put her position on hold until the legal process was completed.

“That was a mistake because it has no justice,” Lundgren said.

“The termination was absolutely wrong. That was unnecessary, totally unnecessary.”

Dalelv was sacked in a letter signed by Al Mana Interiors boss Wissam Al Mana. “... your employment agreement is termination due to your unacceptable and improper behavior [sic] during your last business trip in Dubai, which has resulted in your arrest by the Police Authorities in UAE,” the termination letter dated April 9 says.

 

Lundgren said both Dalelv and the Sudanese colleague who was accused of raping her and sentenced to 13 months’ jail for extramarital sex would be offered back their jobs.

“If she wants to work [in Doha] or for us she has a job,” he said.

“He [Al Mana] has no problem with her, I can promise you that.

“Me and [Al Mana] have had long discussions about this and me and him feel we should have been much more involved.”

Dalelv would be offered whatever support she wanted – and so too would the male colleague.

“It’s all about what she wants,” Lundgren said. “She will tell me exactly what she wants and I will help her with anything she needs.

“But I will do that for the other guy also. I will not treat them differently, that would be absolutely unethical.”

Dalelv, an interior designer, was in Dubai for a short business trip in March when she claims she was raped by her colleague after she asked him to escort her to her room at the end of a work event where they had both been drinking alcohol.

She was charged with extramarital sex and illegally drinking alcohol after reporting the incident to police.

She said she was later advised by an Al Mana Interiors manager to say the sex was voluntary and the matter would be dismissed. However, she was then also charged with making a false statement.

Lundgren said he would not make any judgment on either former employee.

“He says he didn’t do it,” he said. “Did he do it, did she [lie]? I don’t know.”

Lundgren said he had seen parts of hotel video footage showing the pair leaving the event and walking to a hotel room.

“She followed him into the room and what happened in that room is between two people and it’s up to the legal system to decide that,” he said.

“There is a legal system in the Middle East and if you [are] in the Middle East you have to live by the rules in the Middle East.”

A statement released on Sunday by Al Mana Interiors said it had supported Dalelv throughout the ordeal.

“We are sympathetic to Marte Dalelv during this very difficult situation,” the statement said.

“Only when Ms. Dalelv declined to have positive and constructive discussions about her employment status, and ceased communication with her employer, was the company forced to end our relationship with her.

“The decision had nothing to do with the rape allegation, and unfortunately neither Ms. Dalelv nor her attorneys have chosen to contact the company to discuss her employment status.

“We continue to be open to helping Ms. Dalelv and extending her resources during the Dubai legal process. We are hopeful that we can resume a positive discussion about the assistance she needs during this difficult time.”

Arabian Business: why we're going behind a paywall

Real news, real analysis and real insight have real value – especially at a time like this. Unlimited access ArabianBusiness.com can be unlocked for as little as $4.75 per month. Click here for more details.
Really 7 years ago

If he has seen her walk into the room after him on video footage then she lie to the world about being dragged into the room, if she lied about that what else did she lie about? The fact she was charged and convicted of perjury would not make me want to employ her! it goes towards her ethics and trustworthiness!

Vicks 7 years ago

Had to wait until the pardon came through. Bit too late in the day, don't you think?

Faris Khan 7 years ago

It is clear that UAE is not a safe place for women ,and nor do they seem to respect women. Why do they let them in simply to abuse them ?.

Omar 7 years ago

Dear Mr.Khan,

The reason this case has gained a lot of attention is because rape is very rare in this part of the world. In the US where you are located however it is more common and would not attract much attention since it is considered "just another case", as are roberries, murders etc . The UAE is a VERY SAFE PLACE ON MANY LEVELS - you wouldn't understand unless you experienced it first hand Mr.Khan...

Walid 7 years ago

I agreed with Really

Lloyd Gomez 7 years ago

I have been following this story , I really appreicate Mr.Lundgren for his open mind and his good heart. Salute you Mr.Lundgren you are a real gentleman. may god bless your tribe..may your tribe multilply !!! I personally feel sad for Ms.Dalelv , I can only console you with my prayers..and next time take it easy on your drinks...see the misery it has brought to your life...a scar that will take time to heal...all of us make mistakes ...but once you know what put you in this situation one should be extra careful in future.

Really 7 years ago

I really want to know why everyone is so happy to believe her account of the events, which change with each media interview when the police, medical examiner, prosecutor, Dubai judge all found that there was not any evidence at all of rape.
They charged her with filing a false claim after the medical reports were released and the video footage was examined. But they are all wrong are they and she is right? Why?

HDee 7 years ago

Hello .... my friend . Would U be so concerned had there been a female from another country ! Just want to get yourself into the picture , for what !!

Andy 7 years ago

Mr.Lundgren your decision to support both and offer jobs to both does not make sense. You are not willing to make a judgement call then fine, but don't forget one of them is lying! So you are going to support and offer job to either a liar and rapist or someone who got drunk, had sex and then claimed she was raped? Harsh but true, you cant have it both ways Mr. Lundgren.

DayWalker 7 years ago

Offering her her job back will definitely not help her get over the fact that Al Mana Interiors decided to ditch her to save face. If she does take her job back, it will be interesting to see how she will face those who made the decision to send her the letter terminating her contract. I hope she is able to move on with another employer in different surroundings.