Canny GCC states Saudi, UAE see voting rights as step on the path to taxation
The king of Saudi Arabia has lived up to his reformist reputation by giving women the right to vote in future elections. A day earlier, neighbouring UAE held the country's second elections.
The changes mean both countries are still far from Western concepts of democracy and nearby revolutions, but the reforms have financial benefits too.
It is easy to pick holes. The right of Saudi women to vote and be part of municipal councils renders them as powerless as their male counterparts: elections only fill half the seats, which have limited powers to start with.
As it stands, women would still need a male driver to reach the polling station - though that may also change by the time they are allowed to exercise their new freedom, in 2015.
Next week's vote, which has been delayed since 2009, will remain a men-only affair.
Women, or at least some, were able to vote and run in the UAE elections for half of the 40-seat Federal National Council held at the weekend.
But the expanded electoral roll remained limited to just 129,000 of the population of roughly 1 million that count as Emirati nationals. And the authorities didn't give any clue on criteria of voting eligibility. Turnout was mere 28 percent.
But Saudi's decision to give women the vote and the UAE's earlier move to expand the electoral roll for its elections are more than sops to the Arab Spring. Bringing women into the political arena provides at least some hope they will be meaningfully involved later.
Furthermore, increasing representation is vital as the six Gulf oil exporting nations seek to reduce their economic dependence on oil.
There are plans to introduce a value-added tax by 2015. VAT at 5 percent could generate 6-9 percent of Gulf budgets, the bloc estimates.
At current rates of government spending and energy consumption, both the UAE and Saudi will eventually need to implement some type of income tax. The tiny steps to democracy in these Gulf countries are about insuring stability.
But they may also be financially prudent, as governments may have come to realise that taxation works better with representation.
(Una Galani is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are her own.)
"No taxation without representation"
A slogan that emerged before the American Revolution. It means "We won't pay taxes to you unless we have some say in the government". Don't tax us if we can't say whats right and wrong.
Don't make us pay money to the government if we can't participate in that government.
This raises some interesting questions;
Can an Advisory body with a large percentage of its members appointed, and has no real legislative powers or decision making authority be considered as "Representation".
What about the large numbers of expats, will they also pay taxes even if they have no representation at all?
I think these small steps were taken to give Saudi citizens a sense of participation, and that their government is slowly moving in the right direction. This is a response to winds of change from the Arab Spring and not nearly enough to support imposing taxes.
Media reports say VAT and income tax plans have been put on hold for the time being.
This is yet another in a series of news pieces from the same journalist, coincidentally, that shows an acute lack of understanding of how the GCC Countries work. Giving women the right to vote has hardly any relation to plans to introduce a VAT. They are on 2 separate dimensions, if not planets, in terms of their overall effect on each country.
Taxation in the Gulf? Well the last expat to leave can turn out the lights on his way to the airport.