By Shane McGinley
GCC states may clampdown on sales to pacify critics in wake of Arab Spring unrest
Qatar’s move to ban the sale of alcohol on its flagship
Pearl development may hint at the start of a Gulf-wide clampdown on booze sales
as governments look to pacify local fears, analysts said.
The GCC states may move to rein in sales and tighten alcohol
legislation in a bid to walk the line between the expatriate population and their
Muslim citizens in the wake of the Arab Spring unrest, said Guy Wilkinson,
managing partner at Dubai hospitality consultancy, Viability.
“Qatar is hardly the first Gulf state in which the local
population has expressed its concerns over the sale of alcohol,” he told
Arabian Business. “Following the Arab Spring, I expect Muslim parties to have
more and more influence over the control of alcohol throughout the region.”
The sale of alcohol is strictly monitored in five of the
Gulf states with Saudi Arabia operating an outright ban on the sale and
consumption of liquor.
The move to offer alcohol licenses to outlets and
non-Muslims is largely a nod to the region’s expatriate workers, who vastly
outnumber the local population. But the decision has been met with criticism
from some citizens who oppose the sale of liquor in Muslim countries.
Qatar retains comparatively tight rules governing alcohol
consumption, said Wilkinson.
“Just a few years back, one could only find it in just a few
luxury hotels and clubs with strict entry procedures,” he said. “The fact that
its population has increased so fast over the last few years has evidently not
changed the concerns of Muslims over the potential ill effects of alcohol
consumption, particularly in terms of moral behaviour.”
A number of Gulf states have seen conflicts over alcohol
regulations in recent years. Pressure groups in Bahrain forced the closure of
bars and clubs in the Gulf state’s three-star hotels in 2009, while Oman has
chosen to confine the sale of booze to certain hotels and restaurants.
Dubai, widely seen as the Gulf’s most tolerant market, last June
banned standalone bars and restaurants from displaying alcohol behind their bars.
Outlets licensed to serve alcohol but located outside hotels
were forced to tint glass doors on fridges, move entire displays and even
re-design whole bar areas to comply with the ban.
Speaking at the time, the manager of Dubai Marina Yacht Club
said he feared the clampdown could impact on business.
“The alcohol display creates an ambience in the restaurant.
People like to see the bottles, it gives a good look to the bar and restaurant.
There might be a bit of a slump in business,” said Hari Haran.
Chiheb Ben Mahmoud, head of Hotel Advisory, for MENA at
Jones Lang LaSalle, said the open sale of alcohol was always a “delicate
balance” for Gulf governments.
“Sometimes, local public opinion is heated up on the back of
a combination of factors. It is common for authorities in these cases to act
swiftly in order to defuse tension and prevent the issue from heating up further
and getting out of control,” he said.
The suspension of sales on the Pearl could be seen as “a
wake-up call or a reminder of the invisible red lines not to be crossed.”
If this is the case, I know a lot of expats that will say goodbye to the GCC. The region will become a hardship posting once again and salaries will have to go through the roof to attract the right skill sets. Not a good sign for inflation.
Whilst recognising that expatriates are living in a muslim country there must be a freedom of choice. ban alcohol and the choice will be that skilled expatriates will leave for more tolerant countries that also require their expertise.
I thought the Arab spring was all about self determination and not being told what to do by autocrats. Cracking down on freedom and tolerance of others seems a strange reaction to the Arab spring.
Of course Gulf governments are free to ban/restrict alcohol use, but this is a step towards the past not the future.
I challenge you,
95% of the expat. cannot get the same advantages in their own country or in any other country . i believe it is the right step , we appreciate and encourage them.
Welcome to the World Cup with no alcohol, no stadiums, no transport, no fans.
the expatriates will not leave because they will not find work in other region .
and GCC countries are free to ban any thing conflicting with their believes.
That is good beginning , we hope also to start seeing ban on the indecent dresses
I must have missed something. I thought the Arab Spring was all about Freedom, the freedom to express yourself, the freedom to vote,the freedom to practise your religion to free the man and women on the street and not be dictated in an unfair way by the people in power.
I never realised that the people rose up and demanded freedom because the were anti-alcohol.
Strange move to ban alcohol from an area designed to attract expats to live ie. The Pearl.
Ultimately the government is free to enforce the laws it see's fit to govern the Country with, but in terms of creating a multi-cultural society open to all...this is a step back.
Learning to live together and to accept others culture is essential to the growth of the Region, espicially if the Region wishes to continue to host major sporting events (lets not forget that Qatar had to gaurantee designated drinking area's and sponsorship by a major international alcohol producer as part of securing the rights to the World Cup)
In short, the Arab world must intergrate Western culture as much as expats must respect and intergrate the culture of the Region....I believe its call harmony, respect and a middle ground!!
Ps. Dont delude yourself expats wont leave (plenty of emerging Countries requiring qualified people currently) and dont think the Region doesnt need the skills to build their visions
Husam, u r so right. If expats could find decent jobs in their own bankrupt countries, few would be in the Gulf....
Talking of which, the Canadian economy is bad....any jobs for me :)