We noticed you're blocking ads.

Keep supporting great journalism by turning off your ad blocker.

Questions about why you are seeing this? Contact us

Font Size

- Aa +

Wed 19 Feb 2014 11:06 AM

Font Size

- Aa +

Qatar human rights boss says rate of Indian deaths is "normal"

Chairman of the gov’t-linked Qatar National Human Rights Committee defends country’s poor construction worker fatality rate

Qatar human rights boss says rate of Indian deaths is "normal"
(Getty Images - Photo for illustrative purpose only)

The head of the Qatar National Human Rights Committee (NHRC) has said the rate of fatalities among Indian workers in the country in the past two years – reported to be 478 – is “normal”.

Chairman of the government-linked NHRC, Ali bin Sumaikh Al Marri, said half-a-million Indians lived in Qatar, working mainly on construction sites, and their deaths were comparable to the natural deaths of locals.

"Indians make up the largest community in Qatar... twice the number of Qatari nationals,” he was quoted as telling global news agency AFP.

"If we look at the numbers of Qataris who died... of natural causes... over the past two years, we see that numbers of deaths among the Indian community are normal."

AFP reported on Monday the Indian embassy in Doha had registered 237 worker deaths in 2012 and 218 in 2013 up to December 5, at a rate of 20 fatalities each month.

The figures, obtained under a right to information request, follow similar data revealed to AFP by the Nepalese embassy in Doha last month, showing 191 Nepali deaths recorded in 2013, with many of them from "unnatural" heart failure, compared with 169 the year before.

Al Maari said he wanted clarifications on the circumstances of the deaths, insisting there was a "campaign against Qatar", reported AFP.

Nicholas McGeehan, the Qatar and UAE researcher for the international rights group Human Rights Watch, told Al Jazeera that while it was not helpful to dismiss the death figures as "normal" and claim it as a campaign against the country when it already has a bad safety record, there was need to clarify the causes.

"We need to hear how the workers died, and we need to find out the extent of how it was related to their living and working conditions," he said.

"The Indian embassy should be as concerned about these figures as the Qataris [...] because they give an indication of an unfolding tragedy in Qatar.”

Qatar has faced mounting criticism from human rights groups over the safety and working conditions of migrants in the construction industry, particularly as it gears up to host the 2022 World Cup.

Football world governing body FIFA has requested a report from Qatar World Cup officials detailing how it had improved safety standards.

In a report presented to the European Parliament last week, the Qatar World Cup organising committee promised that contractors who build its stadiums will be held to high standards on the welfare of migrant workers, although the standards were not widened to include all construction workers in the country.

The committee insisted it was making "tangible progress" toward reform.

Arabian Business: why we're going behind a paywall

Real news, real analysis and real insight have real value – especially at a time like this. Unlimited access ArabianBusiness.com can be unlocked for as little as $4.75 per month. Click here for more details.
Mark X 6 years ago

"If we look at the numbers of Qataris who died... of natural causes... over the past two years, we see that numbers of deaths among the Indian community are normal."

While the Qatari's may have died a natural death owing to age etc, did the Indians also died a similar natural age related death? - Some Self Appointed EXPERTS !!!!!!!

T A Khan 6 years ago

I totally agree with this. The official death rate in India is 8 persons for every 1000. If the population of Indians in Qatar is 500,000/- people then a death of 478 persons over 2 years is not very high. Mind you these persons are working in harsh climatic conditions and may suffer due to this , but this is a choice that the individual has made. It should not be construed as all these deaths are work related accidents , most of them are natural deaths. It again seems like a case of 'gulf bashing" by the western media. This is just my point of view and I am not an expert to condone reports of poor working conditions in Qatar which is reported in the media , but I am sure the reality is quite different than what is projected in the media.

Ambuj Tripathi 6 years ago

It would be interesting to see what the Indian Embassy has to say on these deaths. Are they acting as mere book keepers (counting the numbers ) or have details on the nature and reason for these deaths. Qatar can explain later

rednrosy 6 years ago

strange statistics, they base it upon the entire popuulation which includes very young and also very old, instead of looking at the rates of the same peer group, and the rates of accidents not natural causes.

Anon 6 years ago

The point here is they are not interested.

F Backer 6 years ago

If the most number of deaths is work related then its a concern.

Resla 6 years ago

Yes ofcourse, in general we indians don't like to leave the Gulf see the streets of Doha we dominate in number...how its possible not to be in the death...if that is the case let our Embassy to find the reason behind... this is a campaign of western medias....towards their hiden agendas...

Mark Williams 6 years ago

International Trade Union Confederation (ITUC) said the data showed an "exceptionally high mortality rate

@Resla - Yes blame the West and their 'hidden agenda' what is hidden about questioning the mortality rates of these workers which are rated as exceptionally high. The fact that you dismiss these statistics in favour of a conspiracy says a great deal about your attitudes to your fellow countrymen.

SA1 6 years ago

Smear campaign - that started once FIFA started talking about shifting the schedule.

Are these work-related deaths or normal? why is the Smear Campaign silent about this. This is 480 deaths per million per year....what is the figure in developed countries?

tfg 6 years ago

Smear campaign and exaggerations that wont stop until the world cup gets hosted.

Why don't they talk about "human rights" of coal miners and other mining industries?