We noticed you're blocking ads.

Keep supporting great journalism by turning off your ad blocker.

Questions about why you are seeing this? Contact us

Font Size

- Aa +

Tue 23 Nov 2010 12:00 AM

Font Size

- Aa +

The human touch

CID speaks to Galal Mahmoud, CEO of GM Architects, about context, humanity and design.

The human touch
The human touch
The Park Rotana is a business hotel with a beach feel.
The human touch
GM Architects was responsible for the interiors \nof the Park Rotana in Abu Dhabi.
The human touch
GM Architects was responsible for the interiors \nof the Park Rotana in Abu Dhabi.

In 1996, Galal Mahmoud returned to Lebanon, after 20 years away. He had
spent the previous two decades studying and working in France, but his
childhood home was calling him back.

At the time, Lebanon
was edging into a period of peace and reconstruction, presenting interesting opportunities
for an open-minded, internationally-trained architect and interior designer. Mahmoud
founded GM Architects, an architecture and interior design firm eager to contribute
to the shaping of a new Lebanon.
The Beirut office was also envisaged as a springboard
into the
rest of the Middle East and by 2005
the company had also established a presence in Abu Dhabi.

Over the years, GM Architects has come to specialise in hospitality
projects, particularly beachfront resorts. It is Mahmoud’s rootlessness that defines
his work – in that it has instilled an almost instinctual versatility. Context and
humanity are key.

CID met with Mahmoud at the Park Rotana Abu Dhabi, one of his
latest projects in the UAE, to find out more about Beirut’s unique design language, and the importance
of scale, reason  and context in design.

Tell us about your career so far.

I graduated in architecture, in Paris, and started a business there in 1986. I
worked in France for over ten
years, doing mainly retail, luxury hotels and residential projects in Paris, New York, Florida and also South America.

I started moving back to Lebanon, which is where I am from originally,
in 1996. Business picked up extremely quickly and I slowly reduced my activities
in France.
In 2000, I shut down the office in Paris to focus
more on Lebanon, always knowing
that Lebanon would be a starting
point for the rest of the Middle East.

In Lebanon
we focused on commercial, restaurant and hospitality projects. The nice thing about
Beirut is that it
is a showcase for designers. The entire Arab world goes on vacation in Beirut and anything that’s
new and upcoming, they want in their own countries. So it was a perfect display
case for us.

Through our activities in Beirut,
we started getting projects elsewhere in the Middle East.
It picked up gradually and then with the boom in the UAE, we decided to open an
office in Abu Dhabi
in 2005 that would cater for the entire UAE, plus other countries in the region.
We now cover most of the Middle East, and are starting to grow towards northern
Africa, all the way to Spain
and Eastern Europe. We’ve done projects in Turkey, Greece,
Egypt and Morocco, and will maybe end up coming back to Europe one day, which I’d ultimately like.

From around five or six years ago, one of our main areas of activity
has been hotels but, more specifically, beachfront resorts. I would say that this
is the direction that we are taking now. We are currently working on a five-star
resort in Morocco, on the Mediterranean Sea. We also have one coming up on the Red Sea
in Egypt and another on the Dead
Sea in Jordan,
so all very nice locations.

I’m an architect but I’ve done a lot of interior design. And
through the experiences we’ve had with interior design, I’m now coming back to architecture.
That means I’m able to design holistic projects, which is what I want to do.

How important is that synergy between interior design and architecture?

Very important, especially in resorts because the experience
that you have in resorts is very complete. There’s no cut-off line, particularly
when the weather’s good. The boundaries are not physically embedded. You can open
up your room and it almost becomes an outdoor space. And your outdoor pergola can
become a semi-indoor space. It all blends together and it becomes very important
to combine both and make sure that they speak the same language.

What are the key trends in hospitality design right now?

The trend is to go very modern, even for resorts. So, less contextual,
more modern, which I have mixed feelings about. Our approach is completely different.
Our approach to a resort is that you are working within a very rich environment,
so it has to be completely integrated.

The architectural look of the building should be very discreet
and blend in completely. It is not supposed to be a statement. On the contrary,
my ideal architecture would be something that disappears completely. It’s more about
the experience, the escapism, the wellbeing and the privacy. And the use of local
culture, local materials and local finishes within a modern vocabulary.

We are not trying to make a statement with the design. The statement
is in the guest experience. This is what will dictate the actual design. So we take
the context, the environment and the topography, and we layer them with what is
our ideal guest experience. This will produce the design. It becomes a synergy of
all these elements.

We are not into Mickey Mouse interpretations of Islamic elements.
If we use Islamic elements, it is because we think they add value to the guest experience.
But there is no point in using them just to say it is a ‘local’ building.

Is that common practice in this region?

It’s been abused. You only have to look at the variety of mashrabiyas
being used. You have to go back to the origin and function of the mashrabiya, and
then use it accordingly. You can’t just design a façade, put a mashrabiya on it
and say I’m filtering light so I am contextual. We try to be more sensible.

What is the sensible approach?

We try to understand the culture and the real use of these traditional
architectural elements. And then, if we need them, we will interpret them in a modern
way and integrate them into our design.

Are there successful reinterpretations of traditional vernacular
in this market?

The problem I have here is the size of the projects. They are
a bit oversized. They cannot be vernacular because they do not correspond to the
scale. They’ve taken a fort and multiplied it by ten, so suddenly you’ve lost all
your references.

When you go to the Far East
and you look at their resorts, they are modern, they are vernacular and they are
also beneficial to the guest experience. They are very successful but then their
size is much smaller. The largest resort you’ll find there is around 150 rooms.

I think you have to come back to a more human scale. We’ve lost
our sense of humanity in this part of the world. Do we need the biggest everything?
It brings in a sense of scale and proportion that is completely out of balance.

Has Lebanon
been more successful in creating design that is sensitive to the culture and the
location, do you think?

In Beirut,
most of the designers are Lebanese. In the UAE you are dealing with very good designers,
but the advantage that we have in Beirut
is that it is in our blood. We do not have to research the culture, because we live
it and we feel it, instinctually. This is what gives us, as an office, the advantage,
even in other countries in the Middle East. We
can understand immediately what are the real cultural values and the real architectural
values, because we have been brought up with those elements.

Have you seen massive change in Beirut since you first opened your office?

is what I call unorganised chaos. But it works. I don’t know how, but it works.
The only thing is we have a major problem with urban planning. The UAE has gone
to the other extreme of over planning, whereas in Lebanon we have no planning whatsoever.

We have a lot of problems with the environment. Even though we
have a fantastic environment, it is being destroyed gradually. We also have an issue
with providing the city with the basic requirements of a city – pavements for people
to walk on, proper streets, green spaces. Everyone is building high rises, which
will create a lot of collateral problems, in terms of traffic and pollution. No
one is thinking in advance.

But it’s an interesting city because it has such an interesting
mix of people. The war impacted four generations, who left and went all over the
world to study and live and experience. Plus the generations that stayed and lived
through the war all had their own experiences.

To live and work during war time is quite something, and it can
have a positive impact. The positive is that it has produced people with such a
strong will to move forward that you will never find anywhere else in the world.

How does the country’s turbulent
history manifest itself in design?

It manifests itself in the fact that the people that stayed are
extremely curious. Unfortunately, they could not travel so instead they tried to
learn through whatever means they had available to them. They are extremely aware
of what is happening around them.

Plus, each person that left and then came back brought their
own experiences with them. So you have this melting pot of people who lived in Italy or Canada
or South America or France or
the UK or the US.

This variety of cultures has created a fantastic dish, which
makes Beirut very
interesting. It is chaotic, but so creative at the same time. Give the Lebanese
people 10 or 15 years of stability and the country will just bloom. Right now we
have cycles of five years, which is a very short amount of time. If you ask an investor
to invest $30 million in a resort in Lebanon, they are going to think twice.
They’d prefer to invest in a residential building because they can sell the apartments
and be done with it.

What projects have you been involved with in Lebanon?

We’ve done a lot of restaurants. Now we are shifting to hotels.
There are a few new hotels coming up, and we also have some renovation projects.
We’ve also created the concept of a day beach resort, which already existed in Lebanon but was
very archaic. It was the 1970s model of a concrete pool, a ladder to the sea and
a fish restaurant.

We’ve taken that and developed
day beach resorts that are comfortable and well designed and have all kinds of facilities,
such as private cabanas, open-air spas, restaurants and so on. This is something
that we have specialised in and will try to introduce to the UAE, because it doesn’t
exist at the moment. Anyone who wants to go to the beach has to pay a hotel $60
to go and sit on a plastic chair.

What are the biggest differences bet -
ween the Lebanese and UAE markets?

The UAE is a far more bullish market. Things have to be done
quickly. The problem we face in the UAE – and it is a nice problem to have – is
that we are not given enough time to really think our projects through, because
everyone is in such a rush. It’s challenging but at the same time, it makes us more

In Lebanon,
you have more time because the owners are far more personally involved in their
projects. They follow up and they want to know what you are doing. Here you are
dealing with a board and the board has budgets and administrators and so on. They
hire you because they know you are good but sometimes you feel like you are just
a commodity, rather than an added value.

You lose control of your projects
because of time and budgetary restraints. You can do a fantastic design and then
suddenly the project is out of your hands because it’s gone out to a contractor
and they start cannibalising it. And once it’s done you are left feeling a little
disappointed. We also have a problem with the quality of the finish because things
happen so quickly that even the best contractor doesn’t have time to do things properly.

However, at the same time, the market in the UAE is much more
bullish, the projects are on a bigger scale, the budgets are bigger than in Lebanon, and the
exposure is far greater for us.

How did you become involved with the Park Rotana project in Abu Dhabi?

We have a privileged relationship with Rotana and they give us
a lot of their properties to design. We started off by doing a Rotana in Sharm El
Sheikh in Egypt
and after that, I assume, positive experience, they listed us for this project.
And once this got started, we started doing other projects for Rotana.

We’ve done one in Dubai, we’re
doing one in Al Ain, we’re doing one in Jordan,
we’re doing another in Abu Dhabi
and we’re doing one in Salalah. We also currently have projects with Sheraton in
Istanbul, Sofitel in Morocco,
Crowne Plaza
in Beirut, and we
are moving into some boutique chains. Le Gray Hotel in Beirut is doing an extension and has asked us
to handle the design of rooms, restaurants and meeting rooms. We will be working
in collaboration with the designers of the original project.

We are trying to shift to the high end of the market, because
we believe that we offer that kind of service. The good thing is that Rotana is
also moving upmarket so we came in at the right time.

Tell us about the Park Rotana design.

The idea was to create a fresh and functional business hotel
but at the same time bring in a bit of our creativity and our ‘beach’ experience.
All of our pro -
jects are quite colourful. So although the hotel is quite corporate, it also has
an element of creativity and a bit of colour and craziness to it.

It is designed to be relaxing, with little splashes of colour
that will bring positivity in. The approach is ‘see and be seen’, so there is a
raised platform in the lobby where people can sit and see who is coming in and out.
But there is also privacy where it is needed.

The rooms have also been developed that way. They are extremely
relaxing, so you can spend your whole day in there, without feeling like you are
in a hotel room. We’ve given priority to the size of the room, so the bathrooms
are small but the room is big. You have your relaxation area, your work area and
your sleeping area, all within one space. By playing with the heights of the ceiling,
each area is given its own identity. We have two colour schemes – red and blue rooms. The red is for
people that need to be energised and the blue is for those that need to unwind.

How did you capture the ethos of the Rotana brand?

The Rotana brand is geared towards the GCC. So we always try
and bring in a Middle Eastern touch. It is sometimes so subtle that it becomes subliminal,
but we keep it in mind. We try to make the GCC user feel comfortable in this environment,
and not create a space that is so modern that they cannot identify. We used touches
of bronze and turquoise, which are very Middle Eastern colours.

Small elements like these make the locals feel like they belong
to the place. They are not thrown into an environment that is not theirs. It’s got
that Middle Eastern touch, but they can’t define it. That’s when you are not pastiche.

What’s your favourite part?

There is no favourite part. For us, every single space within
a project has to be successful. No single space should take priority over another.
In a restaurant, for example, every table should offer a good experience. It can
be a different experience to the other tables, but it should still be a good experience.
You should never have a table next to the kitchen that nobody wants. You are paying
the same bill, so why should you be shoved into a corner by the toilets?

Is there anything about Abu Dhabi that makes it different to other markets?

We know that Abu Dhabi is a bit
more traditional than Dubai.
So although we wanted something modern, we didn’t want to be aggressive. People
are open to modernity but if you go overboard and become overly iconic, there is
a clash. Cultures need time to adapt to a changing world. And you are not creating
a pavilion in a fair, or a laboratory. People have to come here and stay and live
and use, so you need to make sure that they feel good.

Is that another issue on this part of the world? And is it linked
to the number of international designers working here?

There’s nothing wrong with bringing in international architects
and designers because I believe that they bring in a fresh approach, which can be
very interesting. But they have to be given the time to be able to acknowledge what
is happening in the country, and then produce their own vision. If you don’t give
them the time then there is no way that they can understand the culture.

So, on the contrary, I think it’s very positive to have this
mix of designers. They will bring in an angle that I will not think of because I
am so embedded in the local culture.

What are the biggest challenges that you face as a designer at

The time that we are given to produce projects. We are creating
a space that will be used for 15 or 20 years. You cannot create that in three months,
no matter how good you are. And these projects cost a lot of money, so you also
have a responsibility to the client.

Our role as designers is to make people’s lives better. That’s
a big responsibility. It’s not a simple case of a sketch on a piece of paper. This
is the main challenge – making people’s lives better, be it in a hotel room, a restaurant,
an office or in their home. This is what I mean when I talk about humanity.

You have to worry about the human element first. You don’t just
do a drawing and then ask people to fit into that, which happens with iconic architecture.
However, we do need iconic architecture to push the limits. It helps the rest of
us to open our eyes to different approaches to designing a building or space. Look
at the Yas Hotel, for example. It’s a spectacular building. Is it user friendly?
No. Is it easy to maintain? No. But you have to have buildings like that.

Arabian Business: why we're going behind a paywall

For all the latest construction news from the UAE and Gulf countries, follow us on Twitter and Linkedin, like us on Facebook and subscribe to our YouTube page, which is updated daily.
Real news, real analysis and real insight have real value – especially at a time like this. Unlimited access ArabianBusiness.com can be unlocked for as little as $4.75 per month. Click here for more details.