$7.1bn state financial support package for Barwa highlights industry's weakness
Qatar's real estate developers are struggling even as the country embarks on huge infrastructure building plans - a warning to investors that despite the billions which the Gulf state is throwing around, they won't necessarily profit.
A $7.1bn state financial support package announced last month for Qatar's largest listed developer, Barwa Real Estate, and the restructuring of other top developers such as United Development Co and state-owned Qatari Diar, highlight the industry's weakness.
Barwa and Diar have cut staff and sold assets to manage their debt. Last October Barwa announced plans to sell more assets in Qatar and Egypt to pay down loans.
Qatar is competing with Dubai as a regional financial centre, and it does not lack money; its natural gas reserves make it one of the richest countries in the world per capita.
But the performance of its real estate industry in the last few years raises questions over whether it has the population size and glamour to become a major market for property developers and investors.
The tiny desert state has a population of about 2 million, only about 250,000 of them local citizens. That is similar to Dubai's size, but Dubai has the rest of the United Arab Emirates as a hinterland, and so far at least, it is winning the competition to establish itself as a base for professionals who work around the Gulf.
"There's no incentive for people to stay long in Doha," said Matthew Green, head of research at real estate consultancy CBRE in Dubai.
"Doha clearly needs to build on other components of its tourism, leisure and lifestyle aspects. Currently they don't have a leisure market, which is its fundamental difference to neighbouring Dubai."
Morning flights to Doha from Dubai are packed with executives and professionals who prefer to live in Dubai and take the hour-long flight to work in the Qatari capital.
"I take a flight to Doha on Sunday morning and return on Wednesday. Life is more comfortable in Dubai, and my family will never agree to move to Doha," said a Dubai-based consultant who did not wish to be identified due to commercial sensitivities.
Qatari real estate developers are hoping this will change as Qatar launches plans to spend about $140 billion over the next decade on a rail system, a new airport, a seaport, and hundreds of kilometres (miles) of major new roads, in addition to stadiums that will host the 2022 World Cup soccer tournament.
These projects are expected to boost Qatar's population in coming years as engineers, managers and labourers arrive to build them. The government hopes the World Cup will leave Doha established as a major international city.
It is not clear, however, that much of the money being poured into infrastructure building will reach Qatar's real estate developers; a large amount will go to foreign contractors with the size, expertise and experience to handle the projects.
Early last month, for example, Qatar awarded four design and build contracts worth about $8.2 billion for phase one of the Doha Metro. But foreign firms such as Italy's Impregilo and South Korea's SK Engineering & Construction dominated the winning consortiums.
Qatar's Galfar al-Misnad Engineering and Contracting was in a consortium that won one of the contracts, but its share price did not rise significantly in response and it is now languishing near its level at the end of last year. Shares in Barwa are down 3 percent since the end of 2012.
In Dubai, property developers have moved from residential projects into building shopping malls, resorts and entertainment facilities, reducing their exposure to swings in housing prices. In Qatar, this process has not occurred on the same scale.
"Dubai is providing facilities to further develop its tourism sector like water parks, large resort hotels and other entertainment facilities," said Duncan Gray, director and country manager for Qatar at consultancy Colliers International.
"There's currently a general lack of such facilities in Doha and there is limited evidence so far of efforts in that direction."
Some analysts attribute this to the fact that most major Qatari real estate developers are linked to the state through shareholdings, and may therefore focus more on the government's agenda than profit- or investor-driven projects.
In May, Barwa unveiled plans to build a $5.5bn island off the coast of Doha that would include luxury villas and a water park. But the project would also be used to anchor cruise ships providing temporary accommodation for the World Cup; this could help to prevent a shortage of accommodation during the tournament, but might do little to ensure a steady stream of income for Barwa or improve the livability of downtown Doha.
Barwa, 45 percent owned by the real estate arm of Qatar's sovereign wealth fund, has acquired assets in France, Switzerland, Britain and other countries in line with the country's overseas investment strategy.
"The majority of the major real estate projects in Doha are being driven by government and quasi-private organisations," said Gray.
Some analysts believe Doha's residential real estate market is fundamentally undersupplied, which should provide opportunities for developers.
Colliers thinks residential demand will reach about 242,000 units by 2017; based on government projections and the current construction pipeline, it estimates total supply will be only 138,235 units in that year.
Most apartments in Doha are two- and three-bedroom units, with an acute shortage of studio and one-bedroom apartments. As a result, monthly rent for a one-bedroom apartment can go as high as QR10,000 ($2,740) in a middle-income community.
"Right now there's probably more properties priced for the smaller part of the market than the larger majority," said Gray.
But incentives for developers to fill this gap are limited by rules restricting the purchase of properties by foreigners. There are just three designated freehold zones in Doha where foreigners can buy.
This contrasts with Dubai, which has more freehold property zones for foreigners and has established itself as a destination for investors from around the Middle East, despite the crash of its real estate market in 2009-2010. A partial rebound of Dubai property prices this year has helped to attract money that might otherwise have gone to Qatar.
"Opportunities for investors are currently limited in Doha. The market is still relatively young and has as yet not matured in the sense of opportunities - but these will come over time if the economy broadens," said Gray.
I have lived in Qatar for the past 8 years. With the billions that Qatar has spent, and is spending, Doha isn't any more interesting than when I arrived. The country is severely lacking ANY world class leisure/recreation facility. All they build is more malls.
And I don't see it getting any better right up to the World Cup. All the projects are focused on roads, transit, stadiums and hotels to support the world cup.
Qatar is, and never will be, 1/10 as interesting as UAE.
Qatar will never compare with Dubai. This starts with attitude and real vision not petrodollars and ego. Money alone does not bring these vital leadership attributes. Sorry Qatar, maybe in 50 years time?
Lived almost 4 years in Doha,moving to UAE next month.
Extremely disappointed from Qatar.
They dream to be considered like Dubai.....but can only dream and continue to dream.....
Goodbye doha......continue to dream and never wake up!
Neither Qatar nor the UAE cares what the expat labour think about their nation or their cities.
You've gone there for a purpose, money and glamour, being the top. So why compare and contrast? I doubt any of these countries bound and gagged you and brought you there!
Enjoy what each has to offer and move on.
Qatar from outset has vision to be different then Dubai in focus on culture, sports , education and MICE and never had planned to attract leisure except limited high end tourism from GCC , Qatar does not lack funds or vision or capability if wanted can embark on major leisure projects but that it why Qatar is and will be always different then any GCC market so with Doha land completion in few years this will be the USP and all the ongoing planned projects , that is Qatar motive and should be understood and give them credit to think outside the box , however I agree more tourism aspects needs to be implemented especially for locals and expats which it is lacking and beach places otherwise Qatar is Qatar and Dubai is Dubai both are unique and should take place in the history for Expo 2020 and 2022 Good luck to both InshaAllah all potential clients will benefit and visit both places as Qatar is more family attraction Alnoor
Does that explain Qatar's ongoing abuse of labour - see the latest HRW report. Yep they do not care that is certain.
Sorry Sylly, this is what the WORLD thinks, not just the expat labor as you put it. Perception becomes reality.
Qatar has a lot of money but lacks execution capabilities. The ex-Emir and ex-FM, both of whom I hold tremendous respect for, have done an admirable job with their efforts to raise Qatar's profile in the world arena, but they just never got the right team of advisers around them.
I've moved this year from Doha to Dubai and on so many factors that count - infrastructure, professionalism, work ethic, productivity, competitiveness - it's a world of difference in Dubai's favor! Dubai 5, Doha 1.
Its unbelievable how many people fly in on a sunday and out on a Thursday, as the main reason being they will not live in Qatar as they do not want to be tied with the NOC rule - run the risk of joining a company, not liking or even finding a better job with better prospects and not being allowed to move.
If Qatar sorts that out then people will me more willing to move to assist in the development of the country.
Can anyone explain how Barwa has a market cap of $3Billion yet have now assets (now they have been sold to Qatar Diar)?
Dubai and UAE both are unique places in the ME and North Africa region...You can not deny that. They (UAE/Dubai) put a lot of hard work to get to where they are today. As one multinational company telling me you want to succeed in this region first you need to be sucsseful in Dubai and UAE then you can take your business model some where else....That is true, not to mention the real competition that you find in the market, plus you have access to a huge skill and non skills workers willing to work and stay in the country. Even in the many of government sponsored projects you find high skilled UAE nationals that put the works sometimes even more than non-national because of the hight competition and screening. This is the success of Dubai and UAE , and they did not get all those by pouring petro or gas dollars. You need to work hard to go the top you can not buy (always) your place. I wish the best for Qatar...