Dubai hotel faces $16.7m lawsuit over legionnaires

  • Share via facebook
  • Tweet this
  • Bookmark and Share
(ITP Images)

(ITP Images)

Starwood Hotels and Resorts Worldwide is facing a $16.7m (AED61.3m) lawsuit in the US after two guests staying at the Westin Mina Seyahi in Dubai claim they caught legionnaires disease at the property.

The suit claims that Thomas Boyle, from Britain, and Elodie Nogues, from France, contracted the disease after staying at the Westin in January and February of 2009, according to a report in The National.

It claims the health of the pair deteriorated rapidly and resulted in hospital stays.

The disease is a form of pneumonia spread through airborne water droplets, which thrives in water and air-conditioning systems.

Boyle arrived at the Westin with his family on December, 2008, and left several days later, on January 6, 2009.

On his return to the UK, the suit says he developed flu-like symptoms and his health deteriorated rapidly.

He then spent a fortnight in a UK hospital having been diagnosed with the disease.

The paper reported that Nogues started to feel weak and feverish two days after checking into the hotel with her son and a friend on February 14. With her health deteriorating, she returned to France on February 21 where she was also diagnosed with legionnaires' disease.

According to the lawsuit, both plaintiffs were unable to return to their normal lives having suffered from depression and anxiety.

The New York Supreme Court is deciding whether the case can go to trial, a decision that could take up to a year to make.

The National asked for a comment from Starwood on the fact legal proceedings had been launched, but no statement has yet been issued.

Join the Discussion

Disclaimer:The view expressed here by our readers are not necessarily shared by Arabian Business, its employees, sponsors or its advertisers.

Please post responsibly. Commenter Rules

Posted by: Red Snappa

As I recall Dubai Municipality published a statement which said that following tests, no traces of transmission of Legionnaires Disease, were found within the Westin's airconditioning and other service systems.

There was no certification of the 'all clear' by an internationally recognised body which in many experts opinion there should be in cases like this. Also, the original controversy arose, because a well known British cricket statistician, Bill Frindell, had stayed at the hotel and died of Legionnaires not long after on his return to the UK.

A relative of mine who was due at a business meeting in Dubai and involved in Irish cricket, had a booking at the Westin, which he cancelled and moved to another hotel in the Dubai Marina once the news had filtered through.

All comments are subject to approval before appearingTerms and conditions

Further reading

Features & Analysis
Sports in the patriarchal society of Saudi Arabia has long been reserved as an activity for men. (AFP/Getty Images)

Saudi women push for right to play sports

Liberal Saudis consider women who participate in sports to be...

5
IPOs in the Middle East and North Africa plunged 95 percent to their lowest in five years in the first quarter of the year

Steering clear of the stock markets

Listing was all the rage three years ago, but IPOs have since...

CYBER CRIME: More than a week after Iran said it had been the victim of another cyber attack by its enemies, foreign computer experts say they have seen no evidence, and some doubt its existence (Getty Images)

Experts sceptical on new Iran 'cyber attack' claim

Iran has shared no details of alleged new cyber attack; experts...

Most Discussed
  • 142
    Etisalat warns customers of phone call scam

    I just got a call from this number +971507896582 stating that I won 500000AED and that i should check the back of my sim card for some numbers and call... more

    Friday, 25 May 2012 3:04 PM - haja
  • 39
    Saudi Arabia bans use of Western calendar

    Given that the start of the new month is determined by the moon sighting, isn't this going to make organising meetings for the following month a bit tricky... more

    Thursday, 24 May 2012 1:24 PM - Mark Renton
  • 20
    UAE officials warn against marrying foreigners

    I am a UAE national married to an Iranian and her unwavering allegiance is toward Iran and she does not espouse any Arab cause, the same applies with my... more

    Friday, 25 May 2012 11:54 PM - Yasser
  • 8
    English football mulls champagne prize ban

    Taking religion based decisions in such matters is wrong. It sends wrong signals and sets up bad precedence. What next? Will they stop serving beef in... more

    Friday, 25 May 2012 12:15 PM - Skand Bhargava
  • 3
    Dubai banks eye mortgages for foreign buyers

    There are so many promises with no substance out there that even none savvy buyers will think twice before taking risks on Dubai Real estate market. Too... more

    Friday, 25 May 2012 9:19 PM - Bob
  • 142
    Etisalat warns customers of phone call scam

    I just got a call from this number +971507896582 stating that I won 500000AED and that i should check the back of my sim card for some numbers and call... more

    Friday, 25 May 2012 3:04 PM - haja
  • 39
    Saudi Arabia bans use of Western calendar

    Given that the start of the new month is determined by the moon sighting, isn't this going to make organising meetings for the following month a bit tricky... more

    Thursday, 24 May 2012 1:24 PM - Mark Renton
  • 25
    Nakheel targets 'young and trendy' for Palm project

    Palm Jumeirah = Disneyland. Is this the kind of community to invest in for a home ???? or a hotel ? It baffles me why people would invest in an apartment... more

    Wednesday, 23 May 2012 4:13 PM - Paul
  • 20
    UAE officials warn against marrying foreigners

    I am a UAE national married to an Iranian and her unwavering allegiance is toward Iran and she does not espouse any Arab cause, the same applies with my... more

    Friday, 25 May 2012 11:54 PM - Yasser
  • 19
    Iran eyes Google legal action over Gulf naming

    Instead of clinging to anything that reminisces you of your obliterated past, why don't you spend sometime fixing your disgraceful and humiliating present... more

    Tuesday, 22 May 2012 9:30 PM - Fahd